← LoCoMo checklist ↓ full transcripts (.jsonl)

c-hybrid-test

Claims-only · semantic (C-sem) · reader holo3.1 (hyades) · judge same. Full reader→judge transcripts.

accuracy 56.3%

answered 32

correct 18

median ctx 1687 tok

multi-hop 50%

temporal 38%

open-domain 63%

single-hop 75%

32 questions · the AI conversation for each (retrieved claims → reader → judge)

conv-26_q11multi-hop✓ correct1657 ctx tok4767 ms recall

Q: Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?

gold: Sweden

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship impact · changed
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · transition led to · relationship changes
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art timeline · since age 17
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · self journey duration · taken a while
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · undergoes · personal transition
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · has nationality · sweden
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines 18th birthday · occurred when · ten years ago
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · transitioned · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has occupation · student
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · moved from · home country
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · move date · 2019
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · experienced · breakup
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · reflects · personal journey
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · came out · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · met after move · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · moved · to new location
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] breakup · affected · caroline
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · met friends · after moving
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · reflected on · personal journey
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · reflected on · progress since transition
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has challenge · breakup
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · underwent · transition
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · shares · journey
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · finds · freedom
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · found · connected
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · last saw melanie · long ago
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · location · fields
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · experienced · struggles
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · reflects on · personal paths
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship impact",
  "object": "changed",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "transition led to",
  "object": "relationship changes",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art timeline",
  "object": "since age 17",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "self journey duration",
  "object": "taken a while",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "undergoes",
  "object": "personal transition",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has nationality",
  "object": "sweden",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
  "predicate": "occurred when",
  "object": "ten years ago",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "transitioned",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "student",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "moved from",
  "object": "home country",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "move date",
  "object": "2019",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "experienced",
  "object": "breakup",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reflects",
  "object": "personal journey",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "came out",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "met after move",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "moved",
  "object": "to new location",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "breakup",
  "predicate": "affected",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "met friends",
  "object": "after moving",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reflected on",
  "object": "personal journey",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reflected on",
  "object": "progress since transition",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has challenge",
  "object": "breakup",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "underwent",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares",
  "object": "journey",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "finds",
  "object": "freedom",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found",
  "object": "connected",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "last saw melanie",
  "object": "long ago",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "location",
  "object": "fields",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "experienced",
  "object": "struggles",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reflects on",
  "object": "personal paths",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline moved from Sweden.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?
Gold answer: Sweden
Model response: Caroline moved from Sweden.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q11",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?",
 "gold": "Sweden",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1657,
 "retrieval_ms": 4767.3,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship impact",
   "object": "changed",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "transition led to",
   "object": "relationship changes",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art timeline",
   "object": "since age 17",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "self journey duration",
   "object": "taken a while",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "undergoes",
   "object": "personal transition",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has nationality",
   "object": "sweden",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
   "predicate": "occurred when",
   "object": "ten years ago",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "transitioned",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "student",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "moved from",
   "object": "home country",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "move date",
   "object": "2019",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "experienced",
   "object": "breakup",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reflects",
   "object": "personal journey",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "came out",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "met after move",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "moved",
   "object": "to new location",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "breakup",
   "predicate": "affected",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "met friends",
   "object": "after moving",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reflected on",
   "object": "personal journey",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reflected on",
   "object": "progress since transition",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has challenge",
   "object": "breakup",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "underwent",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares",
   "object": "journey",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "finds",
   "object": "freedom",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "connected",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "last saw melanie",
   "object": "long ago",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "location",
   "object": "fields",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "experienced",
   "object": "struggles",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reflects on",
   "object": "personal paths",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship impact\",\n  \"object\": \"changed\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"transition led to\",\n  \"object\": \"relationship changes\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art timeline\",\n  \"object\": \"since age 17\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"self journey duration\",\n  \"object\": \"taken a while\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"undergoes\",\n  \"object\": \"personal transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has nationality\",\n  \"object\": \"sweden\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines 18th birthday\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occurred when\",\n  \"object\": \"ten years ago\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"transitioned\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"student\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"moved from\",\n  \"object\": \"home country\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"move date\",\n  \"object\": \"2019\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"experienced\",\n  \"object\": \"breakup\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reflects\",\n  \"object\": \"personal journey\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"came out\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met after move\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"moved\",\n  \"object\": \"to new location\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"breakup\",\n  \"predicate\": \"affected\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met friends\",\n  \"object\": \"after moving\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reflected on\",\n  \"object\": \"personal journey\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reflected on\",\n  \"object\": \"progress since transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has challenge\",\n  \"object\": \"breakup\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"underwent\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares\",\n  \"object\": \"journey\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"finds\",\n  \"object\": \"freedom\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found\",\n  \"object\": \"connected\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"last saw melanie\",\n  \"object\": \"long ago\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"location\",\n  \"object\": \"fields\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"experienced\",\n  \"object\": \"struggles\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reflects on\",\n  \"object\": \"personal paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline moved from Sweden.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Where did Caroline move from 4 years ago?\nGold answer: Sweden\nModel response: Caroline moved from Sweden.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q13multi-hop✗ wrong1689 ctx tok6370 ms recall

Q: What career path has Caroline decided to persue?

gold: counseling or mental health for Transgender people

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · career transition · counseling career
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · mental health work
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · career question
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has occupation · student
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · mentee
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · advocate
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · values · individual paths
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · motivation for career · helping others
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health jobs
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · continue education
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future plan · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career aspiration · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career aspiration · working in mental health
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks advice · career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks validation · career aspirations
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · motivated by · personal experience
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares future goals · education and career
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · states plan · check out career options
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · career plan · counseling
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline as mother · type · future role
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · commits to · making effort
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · shares · personal goals
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What career path has Caroline decided to persue?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career transition",
  "object": "counseling career",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "career question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "student",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "mentee",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "advocate",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "individual paths",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "motivation for career",
  "object": "helping others",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "continue education",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career aspiration",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career aspiration",
  "object": "working in mental health",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks advice",
  "object": "career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks validation",
  "object": "career aspirations",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "motivated by",
  "object": "personal experience",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares future goals",
  "object": "education and career",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "states plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career plan",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline as mother",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "future role",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commits to",
  "object": "making effort",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares",
  "object": "personal goals",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline has decided to pursue a counseling career, specifically in mental health work.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What career path has Caroline decided to persue?
Gold answer: counseling or mental health for Transgender people
Model response: Caroline has decided to pursue a counseling career, specifically in mental health work.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q13",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What career path has Caroline decided to persue?",
 "gold": "counseling or mental health for Transgender people",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1689,
 "retrieval_ms": 6370.3,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career transition",
   "object": "counseling career",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "career question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "student",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "mentee",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "advocate",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "individual paths",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "motivation for career",
   "object": "helping others",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "continue education",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career aspiration",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career aspiration",
   "object": "working in mental health",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks advice",
   "object": "career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks validation",
   "object": "career aspirations",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "motivated by",
   "object": "personal experience",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares future goals",
   "object": "education and career",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "states plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career plan",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline as mother",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "future role",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commits to",
   "object": "making effort",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares",
   "object": "personal goals",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What career path has Caroline decided to persue?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career transition\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling career\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"career question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"student\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"mentee\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"advocate\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"individual paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivation for career\",\n  \"object\": \"helping others\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health jobs\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue education\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career aspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career aspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"working in mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice\",\n  \"object\": \"career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks validation\",\n  \"object\": \"career aspirations\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivated by\",\n  \"object\": \"personal experience\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares future goals\",\n  \"object\": \"education and career\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"states plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career plan\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"future role\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commits to\",\n  \"object\": \"making effort\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares\",\n  \"object\": \"personal goals\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline has decided to pursue a counseling career, specifically in mental health work.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What career path has Caroline decided to persue?\nGold answer: counseling or mental health for Transgender people\nModel response: Caroline has decided to pursue a counseling career, specifically in mental health work.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q15multi-hop✗ wrong1670 ctx tok4359 ms recall

Q: What activities does Melanie partake in?

gold: pottery, camping, painting, swimming

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · activity · painting
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · enjoys · relaxation
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · enjoys · creativity
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · cafe activity · fun
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · camping trip
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · forest exploration
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · enjoys · motherhood
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie family activity · type · event
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie family activity · activity · played games, ate food, hung out
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · believes in · sharing stories
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has role · friend
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie family day · activities · hanging out
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · enjoys · family time
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · has occupation · work
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie s kids · engaged in activity · exploring
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · engages in activity · running
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · uses activity · painting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · activity with · kids
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · activity with · the kids
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · views life as · learning and exploring
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · life is · learning and exploring
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · will plan · special activity
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · asks question · question about activities
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · discovers · melanie creative activity
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · reading
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie activities · cause · refreshment
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · trail activity
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · asked about · caroline weekend activities
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What activities does Melanie partake in?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "relaxation",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "creativity",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "cafe activity",
  "object": "fun",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "forest exploration",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "motherhood",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family activity",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "event",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family activity",
  "predicate": "activity",
  "object": "played games, ate food, hung out",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "sharing stories",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "friend",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family day",
  "predicate": "activities",
  "object": "hanging out",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "family time",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "work",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie s kids",
  "predicate": "engaged in activity",
  "object": "exploring",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "engages in activity",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "uses activity",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity with",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity with",
  "object": "the kids",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "views life as",
  "object": "learning and exploring",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "life is",
  "object": "learning and exploring",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "will plan",
  "object": "special activity",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks question",
  "object": "question about activities",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "discovers",
  "object": "melanie creative activity",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "reading",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie activities",
  "predicate": "cause",
  "object": "refreshment",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "trail activity",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about",
  "object": "caroline weekend activities",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Painting, camping trip, forest exploration, running, reading, trail activity, mountain camping trip, cafe activity, and activities with kids.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What activities does Melanie partake in?
Gold answer: pottery, camping, painting, swimming
Model response: Painting, camping trip, forest exploration, running, reading, trail activity, mountain camping trip, cafe activity, and activities with kids.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q15",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What activities does Melanie partake in?",
 "gold": "pottery, camping, painting, swimming",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1670,
 "retrieval_ms": 4358.7,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "relaxation",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "creativity",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "cafe activity",
   "object": "fun",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "forest exploration",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "motherhood",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family activity",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "event",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family activity",
   "predicate": "activity",
   "object": "played games, ate food, hung out",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "sharing stories",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "friend",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family day",
   "predicate": "activities",
   "object": "hanging out",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "family time",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "work",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie s kids",
   "predicate": "engaged in activity",
   "object": "exploring",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "engages in activity",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses activity",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity with",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity with",
   "object": "the kids",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "views life as",
   "object": "learning and exploring",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "life is",
   "object": "learning and exploring",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "will plan",
   "object": "special activity",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks question",
   "object": "question about activities",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "discovers",
   "object": "melanie creative activity",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "reading",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie activities",
   "predicate": "cause",
   "object": "refreshment",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "trail activity",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about",
   "object": "caroline weekend activities",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What activities does Melanie partake in?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"relaxation\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"creativity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"cafe activity\",\n  \"object\": \"fun\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"forest exploration\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"motherhood\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family activity\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"event\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family activity\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity\",\n  \"object\": \"played games, ate food, hung out\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"friend\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family day\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activities\",\n  \"object\": \"hanging out\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"family time\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"work\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie s kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"engaged in activity\",\n  \"object\": \"exploring\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"engages in activity\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses activity\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity with\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity with\",\n  \"object\": \"the kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views life as\",\n  \"object\": \"learning and exploring\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"life is\",\n  \"object\": \"learning and exploring\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"will plan\",\n  \"object\": \"special activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks question\",\n  \"object\": \"question about activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"discovers\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie creative activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"reading\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie activities\",\n  \"predicate\": \"cause\",\n  \"object\": \"refreshment\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"trail activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline weekend activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Painting, camping trip, forest exploration, running, reading, trail activity, mountain camping trip, cafe activity, and activities with kids.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What activities does Melanie partake in?\nGold answer: pottery, camping, painting, swimming\nModel response: Painting, camping trip, forest exploration, running, reading, trail activity, mountain camping trip, cafe activity, and activities with kids.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q18multi-hop✗ wrong1698 ctx tok4533 ms recall

Q: Where has Melanie camped?

gold: beach, mountains, forest

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · participated in · camping trip few weeks ago
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] camping trip few weeks ago · participant group · melanie and kids
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping activity · roasting marshmallows
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping activity · campfire stories
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · campfire activity · sharing stories
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping memory · best memories
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · camping trip
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] camping trip · has participant · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · hiking
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · forest exploration
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · participant · melanie
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · participant · melanie family
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie family · enjoys · beach camping
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · shared image · image beach camping
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] image beach camping · depicts · melanie family
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · camping trip
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · attended · beach trip recent
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · visited location · beach
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · has family tradition · family camping trip
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · camping trip
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · responds to question · camping memory
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · plans · camping trip
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · enjoys · camping
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping bonding
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · enjoys · camping with family
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · participated in · camping trip
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · observes · kids fun
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about effect · lgbtq support group
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · appreciates · friendship
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · melanie children
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · activity · camping
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · took break from · pottery
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · had previous conversation with · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · family moments
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] image beach camping · type · photograph

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Where has Melanie camped?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "camping trip few weeks ago",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "camping trip few weeks ago",
  "predicate": "participant group",
  "object": "melanie and kids",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "camping activity",
  "object": "roasting marshmallows",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "camping activity",
  "object": "campfire stories",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "campfire activity",
  "object": "sharing stories",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "camping memory",
  "object": "best memories",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "camping trip",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "hiking",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "forest exploration",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie family",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "beach camping",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shared image",
  "object": "image beach camping",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "image beach camping",
  "predicate": "depicts",
  "object": "melanie family",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "beach trip recent",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "visited location",
  "object": "beach",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has family tradition",
  "object": "family camping trip",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "responds to question",
  "object": "camping memory",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "plans",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping bonding",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "camping with family",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "observes",
  "object": "kids fun",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about effect",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "friendship",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "activity",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "took break from",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Melanie has camped at mountain and beach locations.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Where has Melanie camped?
Gold answer: beach, mountains, forest
Model response: Melanie has camped at mountain and beach locations.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q18",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "Where has Melanie camped?",
 "gold": "beach, mountains, forest",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1698,
 "retrieval_ms": 4532.8,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "camping trip few weeks ago",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "camping trip few weeks ago",
   "predicate": "participant group",
   "object": "melanie and kids",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping activity",
   "object": "roasting marshmallows",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping activity",
   "object": "campfire stories",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "campfire activity",
   "object": "sharing stories",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping memory",
   "object": "best memories",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "camping trip",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "hiking",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "forest exploration",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie family",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "beach camping",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image beach camping",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "image beach camping",
   "predicate": "depicts",
   "object": "melanie family",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "beach trip recent",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "visited location",
   "object": "beach",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has family tradition",
   "object": "family camping trip",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "responds to question",
   "object": "camping memory",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "plans",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping bonding",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "camping with family",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "observes",
   "object": "kids fun",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about effect",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "friendship",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "activity",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "took break from",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "family moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "image beach camping",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "photograph",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Where has Melanie camped?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip few weeks ago\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"camping trip few weeks ago\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant group\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie and kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"camping activity\",\n  \"object\": \"roasting marshmallows\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"camping activity\",\n  \"object\": \"campfire stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"campfire activity\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"camping memory\",\n  \"object\": \"best memories\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"hiking\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"forest exploration\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"beach camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared image\",\n  \"object\": \"image beach camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"image beach camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"depicts\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"beach trip recent\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"visited location\",\n  \"object\": \"beach\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has family tradition\",\n  \"object\": \"family camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds to question\",\n  \"object\": \"camping memory\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"plans\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping bonding\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"camping with family\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observes\",\n  \"object\": \"kids fun\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about effect\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"friendship\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"took break from\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"had previous conversation with\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Melanie has camped at mountain and beach locations.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Where has Melanie camped?\nGold answer: beach, mountains, forest\nModel response: Melanie has camped at mountain and beach locations.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q19multi-hop✗ wrong1625 ctx tok5007 ms recall

Q: What do Melanie's kids like?

gold: dinosaurs, nature

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie and kids · type · family group
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · has child · the kids
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie children
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie children · type · children
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie children · has parent · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie family · has member · melanie children
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · parent of · melanie kids
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie kids · type · children
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie kids · child of · melanie
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie family · has member · two younger kids
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · melanie children
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie children · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · has children · true
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie s kids
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie s kids · type · group
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie s kids · child of · melanie
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · activity with · kids
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · activity with · the kids
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie kids · type · children
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · observed · kids enjoyment
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · has child · kids
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · has sibling · kids
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · has parental role · kids
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] kids · has parent · melanie
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · has children · kids
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · children
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · engaged in · time with kids
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie kids
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie kids · type · children
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · appreciates · friendship
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · took break from · pottery
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · had previous conversation with · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · family moments
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · uses clarinet · self expression
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · appreciation · caroline thoughtfulness

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What do Melanie's kids like?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie and kids",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "family group",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "the kids",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie children",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie children",
  "predicate": "has parent",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family",
  "predicate": "has member",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "parent of",
  "object": "melanie kids",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie kids",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie kids",
  "predicate": "child of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family",
  "predicate": "has member",
  "object": "two younger kids",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie children",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie s kids",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie s kids",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "group",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie s kids",
  "predicate": "child of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity with",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity with",
  "object": "the kids",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie kids",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "observed",
  "object": "kids enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has sibling",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has parental role",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "kids",
  "predicate": "has parent",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "kids",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "engaged in",
  "object": "time with kids",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie kids",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie kids",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "friendship",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "took break from",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Not enough information.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What do Melanie's kids like?
Gold answer: dinosaurs, nature
Model response: Not enough information.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q19",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What do Melanie's kids like?",
 "gold": "dinosaurs, nature",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1625,
 "retrieval_ms": 5006.7,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie and kids",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "family group",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "the kids",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie children",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie children",
   "predicate": "has parent",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family",
   "predicate": "has member",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "parent of",
   "object": "melanie kids",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie kids",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie kids",
   "predicate": "child of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family",
   "predicate": "has member",
   "object": "two younger kids",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie children",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie s kids",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie s kids",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "group",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie s kids",
   "predicate": "child of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity with",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity with",
   "object": "the kids",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie kids",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "observed",
   "object": "kids enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has sibling",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has parental role",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "kids",
   "predicate": "has parent",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "kids",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "engaged in",
   "object": "time with kids",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie kids",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie kids",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "friendship",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "took break from",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "family moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses clarinet",
   "object": "self expression",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciation",
   "object": "caroline thoughtfulness",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What do Melanie's kids like?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie and kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"family group\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"the kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has parent\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has member\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"parent of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"child of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has member\",\n  \"object\": \"two younger kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie s kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie s kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie s kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"child of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity with\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity with\",\n  \"object\": \"the kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observed\",\n  \"object\": \"kids enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has sibling\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has parental role\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has parent\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"engaged in\",\n  \"object\": \"time with kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"friendship\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"took break from\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"had previous conversation with\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Not enough information.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What do Melanie's kids like?\nGold answer: dinosaurs, nature\nModel response: Not enough information.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q3multi-hop✓ correct1682 ctx tok5960 ms recall

Q: What did Caroline research?

gold: Adoption agencies

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · values · nature
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline life · type · life
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · other objects question
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · acknowledges · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes in · sharing stories
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · aims to · promote understanding
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · unique paths exist
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · working together builds understanding
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · received help from · people looked up to
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · help received · helped discover identity
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · connected with · people
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · found · connected
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · found · hope
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · conclusion · i'm off to go do some research
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · conclusion · well, i'm off to go do some research
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · ends conversation · go do some research
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · observed · creativity shines
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · additional source · authenticity
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · shared · story
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · asks · what up
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · describes · brave significance
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · learned · importance support
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds to · question about activities
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · perceived · community growth
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · responds · adoption research answer
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching multiple · adoption agencies
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · believes · moments reveal importance
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What did Caroline research?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "nature",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline life",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "life",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "other objects question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "acknowledges",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "sharing stories",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "aims to",
  "object": "promote understanding",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "unique paths exist",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "working together builds understanding",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "people looked up to",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "help received",
  "object": "helped discover identity",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "connected with",
  "object": "people",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found",
  "object": "connected",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found",
  "object": "hope",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "conclusion",
  "object": "i'm off to go do some research",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "conclusion",
  "object": "well, i'm off to go do some research",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "ends conversation",
  "object": "go do some research",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "observed",
  "object": "creativity shines",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "additional source",
  "object": "authenticity",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "story",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "what up",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "brave significance",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "learned",
  "object": "importance support",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds to",
  "object": "question about activities",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perceived",
  "object": "community growth",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "adoption research answer",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching multiple",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "moments reveal importance",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline researched adoption agencies.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What did Caroline research?
Gold answer: Adoption agencies
Model response: Caroline researched adoption agencies.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q3",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What did Caroline research?",
 "gold": "Adoption agencies",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1682,
 "retrieval_ms": 5959.8,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "nature",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline life",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "life",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "other objects question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "acknowledges",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "sharing stories",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "aims to",
   "object": "promote understanding",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "unique paths exist",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "working together builds understanding",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "people looked up to",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "help received",
   "object": "helped discover identity",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "connected with",
   "object": "people",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "connected",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "hope",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "conclusion",
   "object": "i'm off to go do some research",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "conclusion",
   "object": "well, i'm off to go do some research",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "ends conversation",
   "object": "go do some research",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "observed",
   "object": "creativity shines",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "additional source",
   "object": "authenticity",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "story",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "what up",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "brave significance",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "learned",
   "object": "importance support",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds to",
   "object": "question about activities",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perceived",
   "object": "community growth",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "adoption research answer",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching multiple",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "moments reveal importance",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What did Caroline research?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"nature\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline life\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"life\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"other objects question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"acknowledges\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"aims to\",\n  \"object\": \"promote understanding\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"unique paths exist\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"working together builds understanding\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"people looked up to\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"help received\",\n  \"object\": \"helped discover identity\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"connected with\",\n  \"object\": \"people\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found\",\n  \"object\": \"connected\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found\",\n  \"object\": \"hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"conclusion\",\n  \"object\": \"i'm off to go do some research\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"conclusion\",\n  \"object\": \"well, i'm off to go do some research\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"ends conversation\",\n  \"object\": \"go do some research\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observed\",\n  \"object\": \"creativity shines\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"additional source\",\n  \"object\": \"authenticity\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"story\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"what up\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"brave significance\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"learned\",\n  \"object\": \"importance support\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds to\",\n  \"object\": \"question about activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perceived\",\n  \"object\": \"community growth\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption research answer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching multiple\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"moments reveal importance\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline researched adoption agencies.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What did Caroline research?\nGold answer: Adoption agencies\nModel response: Caroline researched adoption agencies.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q4multi-hop✓ correct1642 ctx tok5868 ms recall

Q: What is Caroline's identity?

gold: Transgender woman

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · gender identity · transgender woman
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · artistic identity · lgbtq artist
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · type · person
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · identity · trans woman
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art role · gender identity exploration
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · identity · transgender
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · gender identity · transgender
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · discusses · gender identity
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · conversations about gender identity are necessary
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · help received · helped discover identity
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · poetry reading celebrated · identities
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · additional source · authenticity
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · has identity · trans person
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] painting embracing identity · artist · caroline
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · evaluation · special
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · communication style · open
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting red shirt

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What is Caroline's identity?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gender identity",
  "object": "transgender woman",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "artistic identity",
  "object": "lgbtq artist",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "identity",
  "object": "trans woman",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art role",
  "object": "gender identity exploration",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "identity",
  "object": "transgender",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gender identity",
  "object": "transgender",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "discusses",
  "object": "gender identity",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "conversations about gender identity are necessary",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "help received",
  "object": "helped discover identity",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "poetry reading celebrated",
  "object": "identities",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "additional source",
  "object": "authenticity",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has identity",
  "object": "trans person",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "painting embracing identity",
  "predicate": "artist",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reveals motivation",
  "object": "support similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline is a transgender woman (a trans woman) and an LGBTQ artist.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What is Caroline's identity?
Gold answer: Transgender woman
Model response: Caroline is a transgender woman (a trans woman) and an LGBTQ artist.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q4",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What is Caroline's identity?",
 "gold": "Transgender woman",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1642,
 "retrieval_ms": 5867.7,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gender identity",
   "object": "transgender woman",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "artistic identity",
   "object": "lgbtq artist",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "identity",
   "object": "trans woman",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art role",
   "object": "gender identity exploration",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "identity",
   "object": "transgender",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gender identity",
   "object": "transgender",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "discusses",
   "object": "gender identity",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "conversations about gender identity are necessary",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "help received",
   "object": "helped discover identity",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "poetry reading celebrated",
   "object": "identities",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "additional source",
   "object": "authenticity",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has identity",
   "object": "trans person",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "painting embracing identity",
   "predicate": "artist",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "evaluation",
   "object": "special",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "communication style",
   "object": "open",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting red shirt",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What is Caroline's identity?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gender identity\",\n  \"object\": \"transgender woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"artistic identity\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq artist\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"identity\",\n  \"object\": \"trans woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art role\",\n  \"object\": \"gender identity exploration\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"identity\",\n  \"object\": \"transgender\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gender identity\",\n  \"object\": \"transgender\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"discusses\",\n  \"object\": \"gender identity\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"conversations about gender identity are necessary\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"help received\",\n  \"object\": \"helped discover identity\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"poetry reading celebrated\",\n  \"object\": \"identities\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"additional source\",\n  \"object\": \"authenticity\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has identity\",\n  \"object\": \"trans person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"painting embracing identity\",\n  \"predicate\": \"artist\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reveals motivation\",\n  \"object\": \"support similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline is a transgender woman (a trans woman) and an LGBTQ artist.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What is Caroline's identity?\nGold answer: Transgender woman\nModel response: Caroline is a transgender woman (a trans woman) and an LGBTQ artist.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q7multi-hop✓ correct1683 ctx tok4754 ms recall

Q: What is Caroline's relationship status?

gold: Single

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · relationship to · caroline
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship outcome · more genuine relationships
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship impact · changed
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship outcome · more genuine
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · transition led to · relationship changes
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship evolution · more genuine
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · friend of · caroline
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · friend of · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] friendship · value to · caroline
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · has acquaintance · melanie
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines friend · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · experienced · breakup
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · friend
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · received support during · breakup
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · values · love
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · is ready · to offer love
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · connected with · people
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · found · connected
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie relationship · type · friends
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie relationship · share · creative interests
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · share friendship · mutual support
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · friendship quality · mutual support
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · relationship · friends
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · appreciation · love details
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · friend of · melanie
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · friend of · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · is · single parent
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · is single parent · true
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · emotional state · hopeful
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · has acquaintance · melanie
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What is Caroline's relationship status?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "relationship to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship outcome",
  "object": "more genuine relationships",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship impact",
  "object": "changed",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship outcome",
  "object": "more genuine",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "transition led to",
  "object": "relationship changes",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship evolution",
  "object": "more genuine",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "value to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has acquaintance",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines friend",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "experienced",
  "object": "breakup",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "friend",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received support during",
  "object": "breakup",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "love",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is ready",
  "object": "to offer love",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "connected with",
  "object": "people",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found",
  "object": "connected",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
  "predicate": "share",
  "object": "creative interests",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "share friendship",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "friendship quality",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "relationship",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "appreciation",
  "object": "love details",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is",
  "object": "single parent",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is single parent",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "emotional state",
  "object": "hopeful",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has acquaintance",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline is a single parent.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What is Caroline's relationship status?
Gold answer: Single
Model response: Caroline is a single parent.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q7",
 "category": 1,
 "question": "What is Caroline's relationship status?",
 "gold": "Single",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1683,
 "retrieval_ms": 4754.1,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "relationship to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship outcome",
   "object": "more genuine relationships",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship impact",
   "object": "changed",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship outcome",
   "object": "more genuine",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "transition led to",
   "object": "relationship changes",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship evolution",
   "object": "more genuine",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "value to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has acquaintance",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines friend",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "experienced",
   "object": "breakup",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "friend",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received support during",
   "object": "breakup",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "love",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is ready",
   "object": "to offer love",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "connected with",
   "object": "people",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "connected",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
   "predicate": "share",
   "object": "creative interests",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "share friendship",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "friendship quality",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "relationship",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "appreciation",
   "object": "love details",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is",
   "object": "single parent",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is single parent",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional state",
   "object": "hopeful",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has acquaintance",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What is Caroline's relationship status?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship outcome\",\n  \"object\": \"more genuine relationships\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship impact\",\n  \"object\": \"changed\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship outcome\",\n  \"object\": \"more genuine\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"transition led to\",\n  \"object\": \"relationship changes\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship evolution\",\n  \"object\": \"more genuine\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"value to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has acquaintance\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines friend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"experienced\",\n  \"object\": \"breakup\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"friend\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received support during\",\n  \"object\": \"breakup\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"love\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is ready\",\n  \"object\": \"to offer love\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"connected with\",\n  \"object\": \"people\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found\",\n  \"object\": \"connected\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie relationship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie relationship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"share\",\n  \"object\": \"creative interests\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"share friendship\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friendship quality\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciation\",\n  \"object\": \"love details\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is\",\n  \"object\": \"single parent\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is single parent\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional state\",\n  \"object\": \"hopeful\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has acquaintance\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline is a single parent.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What is Caroline's relationship status?\nGold answer: Single\nModel response: Caroline is a single parent.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q0temporal✗ wrong1717 ctx tok12218 ms recall

Q: When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?

gold: 7 May 2023

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · volunteers for · lgbtq+ community
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq counseling workshop
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · attended · lgbtq workshop
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] lgbtq workshop · impacted · caroline
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · advocates for · lgbtq community
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] lgbtq support group · has effect on · caroline
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · reflected on · lgbtq rights
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · joined · connected lgbtq activists
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · found event powerful · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · source of support · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · source of courage · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] lgbtq support group · attended by · caroline
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · emotional cause · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares experience · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares personal experience · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] lgbtq support group · caused in · caroline
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · initiates topic · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · attends event · lgbtq support group
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · volunteered at · lgbtq youth center
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · made connections at · lgbtq youth center
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · joined organization · connected lgbtq activists
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] connected lgbtq activists · has member · caroline
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] connected lgbtq activists · has founding member · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · chose agency because · lgbtq+ support
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · joined · lgbtq mentorship program
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · helps · lgbtq community
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · attended · lgbtq pride event
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · visited · lgbtq center
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · evaluation · special

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "volunteers for",
  "object": "lgbtq+ community",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq counseling workshop",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "lgbtq workshop",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq workshop",
  "predicate": "impacted",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "advocates for",
  "object": "lgbtq community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq support group",
  "predicate": "has effect on",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reflected on",
  "object": "lgbtq rights",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "joined",
  "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found event powerful",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "source of support",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "source of courage",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq support group",
  "predicate": "attended by",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "emotional cause",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares experience",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq support group",
  "predicate": "caused in",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "initiates topic",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attends event",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "volunteered at",
  "object": "lgbtq youth center",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "made connections at",
  "object": "lgbtq youth center",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "joined organization",
  "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "predicate": "has member",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "predicate": "has founding member",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "chose agency because",
  "object": "lgbtq+ support",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "joined",
  "object": "lgbtq mentorship program",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "helps",
  "object": "lgbtq community",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "lgbtq pride event",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "visited",
  "object": "lgbtq center",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline went to the LGBTQ support group on May 8, 2023 at 1:56 pm.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?
Gold answer: 7 May 2023
Model response: Caroline went to the LGBTQ support group on May 8, 2023 at 1:56 pm.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q0",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?",
 "gold": "7 May 2023",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1717,
 "retrieval_ms": 12217.8,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "volunteers for",
   "object": "lgbtq+ community",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq counseling workshop",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "lgbtq workshop",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq workshop",
   "predicate": "impacted",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "advocates for",
   "object": "lgbtq community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq support group",
   "predicate": "has effect on",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reflected on",
   "object": "lgbtq rights",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "joined",
   "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found event powerful",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "source of support",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "source of courage",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq support group",
   "predicate": "attended by",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional cause",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares experience",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq support group",
   "predicate": "caused in",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "initiates topic",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attends event",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "volunteered at",
   "object": "lgbtq youth center",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "made connections at",
   "object": "lgbtq youth center",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "joined organization",
   "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "predicate": "has member",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "predicate": "has founding member",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "chose agency because",
   "object": "lgbtq+ support",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "joined",
   "object": "lgbtq mentorship program",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "helps",
   "object": "lgbtq community",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "lgbtq pride event",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "visited",
   "object": "lgbtq center",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "evaluation",
   "object": "special",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteers for\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq+ community\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq counseling workshop\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq workshop\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq workshop\",\n  \"predicate\": \"impacted\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"advocates for\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has effect on\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reflected on\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq rights\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"joined\",\n  \"object\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found event powerful\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"source of support\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"source of courage\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended by\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional cause\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares experience\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused in\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"initiates topic\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attends event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteered at\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq youth center\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"made connections at\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq youth center\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"joined organization\",\n  \"object\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has member\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has founding member\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"chose agency because\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq+ support\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"joined\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq mentorship program\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"helps\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq pride event\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"visited\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq center\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline went to the LGBTQ support group on May 8, 2023 at 1:56 pm.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When did Caroline go to the LGBTQ support group?\nGold answer: 7 May 2023\nModel response: Caroline went to the LGBTQ support group on May 8, 2023 at 1:56 pm.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q1temporal✓ correct1713 ctx tok12153 ms recall

Q: When did Melanie paint a sunrise?

gold: 2022

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · activity · painting
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] sunflower painting · created by · melanie
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · artistic identity · landscape painter
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art form · painting
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · muses · painting
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · question · painting inspiration
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie and children · resulted in · sunset painting
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] sunset painting · created by · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] sunset painting · created by · melanie children
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · owns · painting lake sunrise
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] painting lake sunrise · created by · melanie
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · uses activity · painting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] painting lake sunrise · special to · melanie
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · created · image sunset over lake
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · confirms · yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · shares personal creation · image sunset over lake
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · confirms creation · i painted that lake sunrise
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · confirms authorship · yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · created artwork · melanies sunset painting
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · sunset painting inspired by · sunsets
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · sunset painting has · pink sky
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · created artwork · melanies abstract painting
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · painted sunset because · calming
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · sunset painting created · last week
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · uses painting for · self expression
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · uses painting for · creativity
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · shared image · image sunset
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has occupation · artist
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · created · second painting
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · has completed · second painting
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · observes · kids fun
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about effect · lgbtq support group
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · appreciates · friendship
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · melanie children
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] sunset painting · depicts · sunset
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · took break from · pottery
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] sunset painting · depicts · beach sunset
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · had previous conversation with · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When did Melanie paint a sunrise?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "activity",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "sunflower painting",
  "predicate": "created by",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "artistic identity",
  "object": "landscape painter",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art form",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "muses",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "question",
  "object": "painting inspiration",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie and children",
  "predicate": "resulted in",
  "object": "sunset painting",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "sunset painting",
  "predicate": "created by",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "sunset painting",
  "predicate": "created by",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns",
  "object": "painting lake sunrise",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "painting lake sunrise",
  "predicate": "created by",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "uses activity",
  "object": "painting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "painting lake sunrise",
  "predicate": "special to",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "created",
  "object": "image sunset over lake",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "confirms",
  "object": "yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal creation",
  "object": "image sunset over lake",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "confirms creation",
  "object": "i painted that lake sunrise",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "confirms authorship",
  "object": "yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "created artwork",
  "object": "melanies sunset painting",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "sunset painting inspired by",
  "object": "sunsets",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "sunset painting has",
  "object": "pink sky",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "created artwork",
  "object": "melanies abstract painting",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "painted sunset because",
  "object": "calming",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "sunset painting created",
  "object": "last week",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "uses painting for",
  "object": "self expression",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "uses painting for",
  "object": "creativity",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shared image",
  "object": "image sunset",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "artist",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "created",
  "object": "second painting",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has completed",
  "object": "second painting",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "observes",
  "object": "kids fun",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about effect",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "friendship",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "sunset painting",
  "predicate": "depicts",
  "object": "sunset",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "took break from",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "sunset painting",
  "predicate": "depicts",
  "object": "beach sunset",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Based on the memories, Melanie painted the lake sunrise in 2022 (the year before 8 May 2023, when she confirmed painting it "last year"). The exact date of the painting isn't specified in the available memories.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When did Melanie paint a sunrise?
Gold answer: 2022
Model response: Based on the memories, Melanie painted the lake sunrise in 2022 (the year before 8 May 2023, when she confirmed painting it "last year"). The exact date of the painting isn't specified in the available memories.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q1",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When did Melanie paint a sunrise?",
 "gold": "2022",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1713,
 "retrieval_ms": 12153.1,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "activity",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "sunflower painting",
   "predicate": "created by",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "artistic identity",
   "object": "landscape painter",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art form",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "muses",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "question",
   "object": "painting inspiration",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie and children",
   "predicate": "resulted in",
   "object": "sunset painting",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "sunset painting",
   "predicate": "created by",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "sunset painting",
   "predicate": "created by",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns",
   "object": "painting lake sunrise",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "painting lake sunrise",
   "predicate": "created by",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses activity",
   "object": "painting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "painting lake sunrise",
   "predicate": "special to",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "created",
   "object": "image sunset over lake",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "confirms",
   "object": "yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal creation",
   "object": "image sunset over lake",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "confirms creation",
   "object": "i painted that lake sunrise",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "confirms authorship",
   "object": "yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "created artwork",
   "object": "melanies sunset painting",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "sunset painting inspired by",
   "object": "sunsets",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "sunset painting has",
   "object": "pink sky",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "created artwork",
   "object": "melanies abstract painting",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "painted sunset because",
   "object": "calming",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "sunset painting created",
   "object": "last week",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses painting for",
   "object": "self expression",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses painting for",
   "object": "creativity",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image sunset",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "artist",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "created",
   "object": "second painting",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has completed",
   "object": "second painting",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "observes",
   "object": "kids fun",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about effect",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "friendship",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "sunset painting",
   "predicate": "depicts",
   "object": "sunset",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "took break from",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "sunset painting",
   "predicate": "depicts",
   "object": "beach sunset",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When did Melanie paint a sunrise?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"sunflower painting\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created by\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"artistic identity\",\n  \"object\": \"landscape painter\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art form\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"muses\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"question\",\n  \"object\": \"painting inspiration\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie and children\",\n  \"predicate\": \"resulted in\",\n  \"object\": \"sunset painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"sunset painting\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created by\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"sunset painting\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created by\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns\",\n  \"object\": \"painting lake sunrise\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"painting lake sunrise\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created by\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses activity\",\n  \"object\": \"painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"painting lake sunrise\",\n  \"predicate\": \"special to\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created\",\n  \"object\": \"image sunset over lake\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"confirms\",\n  \"object\": \"yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal creation\",\n  \"object\": \"image sunset over lake\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"confirms creation\",\n  \"object\": \"i painted that lake sunrise\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"confirms authorship\",\n  \"object\": \"yeah, i painted that lake sunrise last year!\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created artwork\",\n  \"object\": \"melanies sunset painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sunset painting inspired by\",\n  \"object\": \"sunsets\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sunset painting has\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sky\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created artwork\",\n  \"object\": \"melanies abstract painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"painted sunset because\",\n  \"object\": \"calming\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sunset painting created\",\n  \"object\": \"last week\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses painting for\",\n  \"object\": \"self expression\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses painting for\",\n  \"object\": \"creativity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared image\",\n  \"object\": \"image sunset\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"artist\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"created\",\n  \"object\": \"second painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has completed\",\n  \"object\": \"second painting\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observes\",\n  \"object\": \"kids fun\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about effect\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"friendship\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"sunset painting\",\n  \"predicate\": \"depicts\",\n  \"object\": \"sunset\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"took break from\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"sunset painting\",\n  \"predicate\": \"depicts\",\n  \"object\": \"beach sunset\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Based on the memories, Melanie painted the lake sunrise in 2022 (the year before 8 May 2023, when she confirmed painting it \"last year\"). The exact date of the painting isn't specified in the available memories.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When did Melanie paint a sunrise?\nGold answer: 2022\nModel response: Based on the memories, Melanie painted the lake sunrise in 2022 (the year before 8 May 2023, when she confirmed painting it \"last year\"). The exact date of the painting isn't specified in the available memories.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q10temporal✓ correct1674 ctx tok6116 ms recall

Q: How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?

gold: 4 years

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · has friend · melanie
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · has friend · melanie
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relationship filtering · kept supportive friends
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · friend of · caroline
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · friend of · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] friendship · value to · caroline
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has support network · friends and family
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines friend · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has friend · caroline friends
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · type · group
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · friendship duration · 4
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · friendship start date · 2019
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · motivated by · caroline friends
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · friend
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has motivation · friends
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · duration · 4
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · met friends · after moving
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · received help from · friends
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · has friend · melanie
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · connected with · people
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie relationship · type · friends
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · share friendship · mutual support
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · friendship quality · mutual support
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · relationship · friends
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] friendship · participant · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · friend of · melanie
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · friend of · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · volunteer duration · since last chat
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · has friend · melanie
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · type · friend
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relationship filtering",
  "object": "kept supportive friends",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "value to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has support network",
  "object": "friends and family",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines friend",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "caroline friends",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "group",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "friendship duration",
  "object": "4",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "friendship start date",
  "object": "2019",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "motivated by",
  "object": "caroline friends",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "friend",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has motivation",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "duration",
  "object": "4",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "met friends",
  "object": "after moving",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "connected with",
  "object": "people",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "share friendship",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "friendship quality",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "relationship",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "friend of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "volunteer duration",
  "object": "since last chat",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "friend",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

4 years (started in 2019)

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?
Gold answer: 4 years
Model response: 4 years (started in 2019)

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q10",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?",
 "gold": "4 years",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1674,
 "retrieval_ms": 6116.1,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relationship filtering",
   "object": "kept supportive friends",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "value to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has support network",
   "object": "friends and family",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines friend",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "caroline friends",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "group",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "friendship duration",
   "object": "4",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "friendship start date",
   "object": "2019",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "motivated by",
   "object": "caroline friends",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "friend",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has motivation",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "duration",
   "object": "4",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "met friends",
   "object": "after moving",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "connected with",
   "object": "people",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie relationship",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "share friendship",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "friendship quality",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "relationship",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "friend of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "volunteer duration",
   "object": "since last chat",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "friend",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship filtering\",\n  \"object\": \"kept supportive friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"value to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has support network\",\n  \"object\": \"friends and family\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines friend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"group\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friendship duration\",\n  \"object\": \"4\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friendship start date\",\n  \"object\": \"2019\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivated by\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"friend\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has motivation\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"duration\",\n  \"object\": \"4\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met friends\",\n  \"object\": \"after moving\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"connected with\",\n  \"object\": \"people\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie relationship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"share friendship\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friendship quality\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"friend of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteer duration\",\n  \"object\": \"since last chat\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"friend\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "4 years (started in 2019)",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: How long has Caroline had her current group of friends for?\nGold answer: 4 years\nModel response: 4 years (started in 2019)\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q12temporal✓ correct1645 ctx tok6236 ms recall

Q: How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?

gold: 10 years ago

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · occupation · artist
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · type · person
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · artistic career start age · 17
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art timeline · since age 17
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · self journey duration · taken a while
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · has nationality · sweden
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines grandma · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines childhood · type · life stage
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines childhood · label · when caroline was young
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines friend · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] hand painted bowl · given on occasion · carolines 18th birthday
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines 18th birthday · type · birthday event
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines 18th birthday · occurred when · ten years ago
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has occupation · student
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · came out · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · moved · to new location
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · connected with · people
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] friendship · participant · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · has child · melanie
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · has occupation · artist
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · evaluation · special

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "occupation",
  "object": "artist",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "artistic career start age",
  "object": "17",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art timeline",
  "object": "since age 17",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "self journey duration",
  "object": "taken a while",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has nationality",
  "object": "sweden",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines grandma",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines childhood",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "life stage",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines childhood",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "when caroline was young",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines friend",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "hand painted bowl",
  "predicate": "given on occasion",
  "object": "carolines 18th birthday",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "birthday event",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
  "predicate": "occurred when",
  "object": "ten years ago",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "student",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "came out",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "moved",
  "object": "to new location",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "connected with",
  "object": "people",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "artist",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Ten years ago.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?
Gold answer: 10 years ago
Model response: Ten years ago.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q12",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?",
 "gold": "10 years ago",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1645,
 "retrieval_ms": 6236.3,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "occupation",
   "object": "artist",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "artistic career start age",
   "object": "17",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art timeline",
   "object": "since age 17",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "self journey duration",
   "object": "taken a while",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has nationality",
   "object": "sweden",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines grandma",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines childhood",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "life stage",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines childhood",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "when caroline was young",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines friend",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "hand painted bowl",
   "predicate": "given on occasion",
   "object": "carolines 18th birthday",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "birthday event",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines 18th birthday",
   "predicate": "occurred when",
   "object": "ten years ago",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "student",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "came out",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "moved",
   "object": "to new location",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "connected with",
   "object": "people",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "artist",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "evaluation",
   "object": "special",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"artist\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"artistic career start age\",\n  \"object\": \"17\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art timeline\",\n  \"object\": \"since age 17\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"self journey duration\",\n  \"object\": \"taken a while\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has nationality\",\n  \"object\": \"sweden\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines grandma\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines childhood\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"life stage\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines childhood\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"when caroline was young\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines friend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"hand painted bowl\",\n  \"predicate\": \"given on occasion\",\n  \"object\": \"carolines 18th birthday\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines 18th birthday\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"birthday event\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines 18th birthday\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occurred when\",\n  \"object\": \"ten years ago\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"student\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"came out\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"moved\",\n  \"object\": \"to new location\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"connected with\",\n  \"object\": \"people\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"artist\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Ten years ago.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: How long ago was Caroline's 18th birthday?\nGold answer: 10 years ago\nModel response: Ten years ago.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q5temporal✗ wrong1662 ctx tok6117 ms recall

Q: When did Melanie run a charity race?

gold: The sunday before 25 May 2023

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · volunteers at · homeless shelter
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · volunteers with · family
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · volunteered on · yesterday
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] volunteering at shelter · participant · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie and children · has participant · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie family · supported · melanie
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has goal · make a difference
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · faces · challenges
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · received · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · provides · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has · hope
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · wants · to help others
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · aims to · create hope
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has goal · create hope
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · has occupation · work
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · engages in activity · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · benefit for · melanie
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · commits to · continue running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · encouraged · melanie to continue running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · committed to · continue running
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · attended event · pride fest
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] friendship · participant · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · attended · show
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] park visit · participant · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · commented on · volunteering
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · participant · melanie
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · participated in · charity race mental health
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · caused · melanie thinking about mental health care
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] trail activity · participant · melanie
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] trail activity · occurred · 2023 10 19
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When did Melanie run a charity race?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "volunteers at",
  "object": "homeless shelter",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "volunteers with",
  "object": "family",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "volunteered on",
  "object": "yesterday",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie and children",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie family",
  "predicate": "supported",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has goal",
  "object": "make a difference",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "faces",
  "object": "challenges",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "received",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "provides",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has",
  "object": "hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "wants",
  "object": "to help others",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "aims to",
  "object": "create hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has goal",
  "object": "create hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "work",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "engages in activity",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "benefit for",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "commits to",
  "object": "continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "encouraged",
  "object": "melanie to continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "committed to",
  "object": "continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "pride fest",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "show",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "park visit",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "volunteering",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "charity race mental health",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "caused",
  "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "trail activity",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "trail activity",
  "predicate": "occurred",
  "object": "2023 10 19",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

May 25, 2023

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When did Melanie run a charity race?
Gold answer: The sunday before 25 May 2023
Model response: May 25, 2023

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q5",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When did Melanie run a charity race?",
 "gold": "The sunday before 25 May 2023",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1662,
 "retrieval_ms": 6116.5,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "volunteers at",
   "object": "homeless shelter",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "volunteers with",
   "object": "family",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "volunteered on",
   "object": "yesterday",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie and children",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie family",
   "predicate": "supported",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has goal",
   "object": "make a difference",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "faces",
   "object": "challenges",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "received",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "provides",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has",
   "object": "hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "wants",
   "object": "to help others",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "aims to",
   "object": "create hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has goal",
   "object": "create hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "work",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "engages in activity",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "benefit for",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "commits to",
   "object": "continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "encouraged",
   "object": "melanie to continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "committed to",
   "object": "continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "pride fest",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "show",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "park visit",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "volunteering",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "charity race mental health",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "caused",
   "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "trail activity",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "trail activity",
   "predicate": "occurred",
   "object": "2023 10 19",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When did Melanie run a charity race?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteers at\",\n  \"object\": \"homeless shelter\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteers with\",\n  \"object\": \"family\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteered on\",\n  \"object\": \"yesterday\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"volunteering at shelter\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie and children\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"predicate\": \"supported\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has goal\",\n  \"object\": \"make a difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"faces\",\n  \"object\": \"challenges\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has\",\n  \"object\": \"hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants\",\n  \"object\": \"to help others\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"aims to\",\n  \"object\": \"create hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has goal\",\n  \"object\": \"create hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"work\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"engages in activity\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"benefit for\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commits to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"encouraged\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie to continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"committed to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"pride fest\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"show\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"park visit\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"volunteering\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie thinking about mental health care\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"trail activity\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"trail activity\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occurred\",\n  \"object\": \"2023 10 19\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "May 25, 2023",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When did Melanie run a charity race?\nGold answer: The sunday before 25 May 2023\nModel response: May 25, 2023\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q6temporal✗ wrong1700 ctx tok5062 ms recall

Q: When is Melanie planning on going camping?

gold: June 2023

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · participated in · camping trip few weeks ago
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] camping trip few weeks ago · participant group · melanie and kids
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping activity · roasting marshmallows
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping activity · campfire stories
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · asks · future plans
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · campfire activity · sharing stories
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · camping trip
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] camping trip · has participant · melanie
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · forest exploration
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · participant · melanie
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · participant · melanie family
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · shared image · image beach camping
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · camping trip
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · agrees to · special trip summer
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · will plan · special activity
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · asks · next time plans
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · has family tradition · family camping trip
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · camping trip
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · responds to question · camping memory
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · wants to stay present for · family
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · plans · camping trip
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · asks · question about summer plans
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · enjoys · camping
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping activities
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · camping bonding
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · enjoys · camping with family
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · participated in · camping trip
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · appreciates · friendship
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · melanie children
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] family camping · activity · camping
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · took break from · pottery
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · had previous conversation with · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · family moments
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · uses clarinet · self expression

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When is Melanie planning on going camping?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "camping trip few weeks ago",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "camping trip few weeks ago",
  "predicate": "participant group",
  "object": "melanie and kids",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "camping activity",
  "object": "roasting marshmallows",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "camping activity",
  "object": "campfire stories",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "future plans",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "campfire activity",
  "object": "sharing stories",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "camping trip",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "forest exploration",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie family",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shared image",
  "object": "image beach camping",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "agrees to",
  "object": "special trip summer",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "will plan",
  "object": "special activity",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "next time plans",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has family tradition",
  "object": "family camping trip",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "responds to question",
  "object": "camping memory",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "wants to stay present for",
  "object": "family",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "plans",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "question about summer plans",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping activities",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping bonding",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "camping with family",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "friendship",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "family camping",
  "predicate": "activity",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "took break from",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Melanie is planning a camping trip for summer (as of August 17, 2023).

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When is Melanie planning on going camping?
Gold answer: June 2023
Model response: Melanie is planning a camping trip for summer (as of August 17, 2023).

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q6",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When is Melanie planning on going camping?",
 "gold": "June 2023",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1700,
 "retrieval_ms": 5062.2,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "camping trip few weeks ago",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "camping trip few weeks ago",
   "predicate": "participant group",
   "object": "melanie and kids",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping activity",
   "object": "roasting marshmallows",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping activity",
   "object": "campfire stories",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "future plans",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "campfire activity",
   "object": "sharing stories",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "camping trip",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "forest exploration",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie family",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image beach camping",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "agrees to",
   "object": "special trip summer",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "will plan",
   "object": "special activity",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "next time plans",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has family tradition",
   "object": "family camping trip",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "responds to question",
   "object": "camping memory",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "wants to stay present for",
   "object": "family",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "plans",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "question about summer plans",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping activities",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping bonding",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "camping with family",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "friendship",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "family camping",
   "predicate": "activity",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "took break from",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "family moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses clarinet",
   "object": "self expression",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When is Melanie planning on going camping?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip few weeks ago\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"camping trip few weeks ago\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant group\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie and kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"camping activity\",\n  \"object\": \"roasting marshmallows\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"camping activity\",\n  \"object\": \"campfire stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"future plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"campfire activity\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"forest exploration\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared image\",\n  \"object\": \"image beach camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"agrees to\",\n  \"object\": \"special trip summer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"will plan\",\n  \"object\": \"special activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"next time plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has family tradition\",\n  \"object\": \"family camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds to question\",\n  \"object\": \"camping memory\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to stay present for\",\n  \"object\": \"family\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"plans\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"question about summer plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping bonding\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"camping with family\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"friendship\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"family camping\",\n  \"predicate\": \"activity\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"took break from\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"had previous conversation with\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Melanie is planning a camping trip for summer (as of August 17, 2023).",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When is Melanie planning on going camping?\nGold answer: June 2023\nModel response: Melanie is planning a camping trip for summer (as of August 17, 2023).\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q8temporal✗ wrong1665 ctx tok4509 ms recall

Q: When did Caroline give a speech at a school?

gold: The week before 9 June 2023

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] conversation · participant · caroline
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · initiated conversation · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has occupation · student
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] school event · label · caroline's school event
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] school event · organizer · caroline
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · gave talk · school event
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · uses · voice
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · encourages · students
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · discusses · inclusion
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] school event · caused · reflection in caroline
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has resource · voice
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · described event · powerful
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · perceives contribution as · giving voice
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] conversation 2023 07 12 · has speaker · caroline
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · continue education
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · initiates conversation · greeting and inquiry
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · attended on · last friday
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · initiated conversation · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · talked to · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · talked to · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · shared · story
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] conversation · has participant · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · interaction · talking
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · initiated conversation with · melanie
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] conversation · has participant · caroline
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · excitement for · learning advocacy
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · describes · children
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] conversation · has turn · caroline turn1
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] conversation · has turn · caroline turn8
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] conversation · has turn · caroline turn12
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · shared image · image trail
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · communication style · open
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · views art as · creative outlet
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · undergoing · transition
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · praise · great
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] conversation 2023 07 12 · has turn · turn melanie 20
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · provides support · empathy and understanding
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting red shirt
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · camping activity · roasting marshmallows

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When did Caroline give a speech at a school?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "initiated conversation",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "student",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "school event",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline's school event",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "school event",
  "predicate": "organizer",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gave talk",
  "object": "school event",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "uses",
  "object": "voice",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "encourages",
  "object": "students",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "discusses",
  "object": "inclusion",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "school event",
  "predicate": "caused",
  "object": "reflection in caroline",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has resource",
  "object": "voice",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "described event",
  "object": "powerful",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perceives contribution as",
  "object": "giving voice",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation 2023 07 12",
  "predicate": "has speaker",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "continue education",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "initiates conversation",
  "object": "greeting and inquiry",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended on",
  "object": "last friday",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "initiated conversation",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "talked to",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "talked to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "story",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interaction",
  "object": "talking",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "initiated conversation with",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excitement for",
  "object": "learning advocacy",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has turn",
  "object": "caroline turn1",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has turn",
  "object": "caroline turn8",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has turn",
  "object": "caroline turn12",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shared image",
  "object": "image trail",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "communication style",
  "object": "open",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "views art as",
  "object": "creative outlet",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "undergoing",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

9 June, 2023

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When did Caroline give a speech at a school?
Gold answer: The week before 9 June 2023
Model response: 9 June, 2023

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q8",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When did Caroline give a speech at a school?",
 "gold": "The week before 9 June 2023",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1665,
 "retrieval_ms": 4508.9,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "initiated conversation",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "student",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "school event",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline's school event",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "school event",
   "predicate": "organizer",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gave talk",
   "object": "school event",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "uses",
   "object": "voice",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "encourages",
   "object": "students",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "discusses",
   "object": "inclusion",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "school event",
   "predicate": "caused",
   "object": "reflection in caroline",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has resource",
   "object": "voice",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "described event",
   "object": "powerful",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perceives contribution as",
   "object": "giving voice",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation 2023 07 12",
   "predicate": "has speaker",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "continue education",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "initiates conversation",
   "object": "greeting and inquiry",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended on",
   "object": "last friday",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "initiated conversation",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "talked to",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "talked to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "story",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interaction",
   "object": "talking",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "initiated conversation with",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excitement for",
   "object": "learning advocacy",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has turn",
   "object": "caroline turn1",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has turn",
   "object": "caroline turn8",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has turn",
   "object": "caroline turn12",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image trail",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "communication style",
   "object": "open",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "views art as",
   "object": "creative outlet",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "undergoing",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "praise",
   "object": "great",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation 2023 07 12",
   "predicate": "has turn",
   "object": "turn melanie 20",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "provides support",
   "object": "empathy and understanding",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting red shirt",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "camping activity",
   "object": "roasting marshmallows",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When did Caroline give a speech at a school?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"initiated conversation\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"student\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"school event\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline's school event\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"school event\",\n  \"predicate\": \"organizer\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gave talk\",\n  \"object\": \"school event\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses\",\n  \"object\": \"voice\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"encourages\",\n  \"object\": \"students\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"discusses\",\n  \"object\": \"inclusion\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"school event\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused\",\n  \"object\": \"reflection in caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has resource\",\n  \"object\": \"voice\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"described event\",\n  \"object\": \"powerful\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perceives contribution as\",\n  \"object\": \"giving voice\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation 2023 07 12\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has speaker\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue education\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"initiates conversation\",\n  \"object\": \"greeting and inquiry\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended on\",\n  \"object\": \"last friday\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"initiated conversation\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"talked to\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"talked to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"story\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interaction\",\n  \"object\": \"talking\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"initiated conversation with\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excitement for\",\n  \"object\": \"learning advocacy\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has turn\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline turn1\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has turn\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline turn8\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has turn\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline turn12\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared image\",\n  \"object\": \"image trail\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"communication style\",\n  \"object\": \"open\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views art as\",\n  \"object\": \"creative outlet\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"undergoing\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "9 June, 2023",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When did Caroline give a speech at a school?\nGold answer: The week before 9 June 2023\nModel response: 9 June, 2023\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q9temporal✗ wrong1687 ctx tok7286 ms recall

Q: When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?

gold: The week before 9 June 2023

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] conversation · participant · caroline
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · grateful for · friends family mentors support
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · grateful for · friends family mentors
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · support network · friends family mentors
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has support network · friends and family
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · has acquaintance · melanie
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines friend · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · expresses interest · family moments
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has friend · caroline friends
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · type · group
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has mentor · caroline mentors
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline mentors · type · group
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline friends · met after move · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · met friends · after moving
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · received help from · friends
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · contacted · caroline mentor
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline mentor · type · person
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has mentor · caroline mentor
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · connected with · people
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · met people with similar journeys · lgbtq community members
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · met · people with similar journeys
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · found · connected
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline melanie · relationship · friends
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] friendship · participant · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · shared · story
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] connection · participant · caroline
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · excitement for · meeting people
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · describes · family time
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · has acquaintance · melanie
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · has met · young mentees
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] conversation · has turn · melanie turn4
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "grateful for",
  "object": "friends family mentors support",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "grateful for",
  "object": "friends family mentors",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "support network",
  "object": "friends family mentors",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has support network",
  "object": "friends and family",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has acquaintance",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines friend",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "expresses interest",
  "object": "family moments",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has friend",
  "object": "caroline friends",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "group",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has mentor",
  "object": "caroline mentors",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline mentors",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "group",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline friends",
  "predicate": "met after move",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "met friends",
  "object": "after moving",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "contacted",
  "object": "caroline mentor",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline mentor",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has mentor",
  "object": "caroline mentor",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "connected with",
  "object": "people",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "met people with similar journeys",
  "object": "lgbtq community members",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "met",
  "object": "people with similar journeys",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "found",
  "object": "connected",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline melanie",
  "predicate": "relationship",
  "object": "friends",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "story",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "connection",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excitement for",
  "object": "meeting people",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "family time",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has acquaintance",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has met",
  "object": "young mentees",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "conversation",
  "predicate": "has turn",
  "object": "melanie turn4",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Not enough information.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?
Gold answer: The week before 9 June 2023
Model response: Not enough information.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q9",
 "category": 2,
 "question": "When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?",
 "gold": "The week before 9 June 2023",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1687,
 "retrieval_ms": 7286.1,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "grateful for",
   "object": "friends family mentors support",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "grateful for",
   "object": "friends family mentors",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "support network",
   "object": "friends family mentors",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has support network",
   "object": "friends and family",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has acquaintance",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines friend",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "expresses interest",
   "object": "family moments",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has friend",
   "object": "caroline friends",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "group",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has mentor",
   "object": "caroline mentors",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline mentors",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "group",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline friends",
   "predicate": "met after move",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "met friends",
   "object": "after moving",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "contacted",
   "object": "caroline mentor",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline mentor",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has mentor",
   "object": "caroline mentor",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "connected with",
   "object": "people",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "met people with similar journeys",
   "object": "lgbtq community members",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "met",
   "object": "people with similar journeys",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "connected",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline melanie",
   "predicate": "relationship",
   "object": "friends",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "story",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "connection",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excitement for",
   "object": "meeting people",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "family time",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has acquaintance",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has met",
   "object": "young mentees",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "conversation",
   "predicate": "has turn",
   "object": "melanie turn4",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"grateful for\",\n  \"object\": \"friends family mentors support\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"grateful for\",\n  \"object\": \"friends family mentors\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"support network\",\n  \"object\": \"friends family mentors\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has support network\",\n  \"object\": \"friends and family\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has acquaintance\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines friend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expresses interest\",\n  \"object\": \"family moments\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has friend\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"group\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has mentor\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline mentors\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline mentors\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"group\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline friends\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met after move\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met friends\",\n  \"object\": \"after moving\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"contacted\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline mentor\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline mentor\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has mentor\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline mentor\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"connected with\",\n  \"object\": \"people\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met people with similar journeys\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq community members\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"met\",\n  \"object\": \"people with similar journeys\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"found\",\n  \"object\": \"connected\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship\",\n  \"object\": \"friends\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"story\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"connection\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excitement for\",\n  \"object\": \"meeting people\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"family time\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has acquaintance\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has met\",\n  \"object\": \"young mentees\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"conversation\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has turn\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie turn4\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Not enough information.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: When did Caroline meet up with her friends, family, and mentors?\nGold answer: The week before 9 June 2023\nModel response: Not enough information.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q14open-domain✓ correct1741 ctx tok5906 ms recall

Q: Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?

gold: Likely no

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · interested in · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · career transition · counseling career
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · mental health work
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · perceives · counseling work as tough
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · observed · counseling benefits
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · career question
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · counseling details question
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · motivation for career · helping others
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health jobs
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] mental health support · enabled · caroline career realization
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] mental health support · inspired · caroline career choice
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career goal · support those with similar issues
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career aspiration · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career motivation · support those with similar issues
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · believes · would be great counselor
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks advice · career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career choice reason · support those with similar issues
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · states interest · keen on counseling
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · career aspiration · counseling and mental health
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · career plan · counseling
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · career plan · mental health
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interested in",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career transition",
  "object": "counseling career",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perceives",
  "object": "counseling work as tough",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "observed",
  "object": "counseling benefits",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "career question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "counseling details question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "motivation for career",
  "object": "helping others",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "mental health support",
  "predicate": "enabled",
  "object": "caroline career realization",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "mental health support",
  "predicate": "inspired",
  "object": "caroline career choice",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career goal",
  "object": "support those with similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career aspiration",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career motivation",
  "object": "support those with similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "would be great counselor",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks advice",
  "object": "career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career choice reason",
  "object": "support those with similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "states interest",
  "object": "keen on counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career aspiration",
  "object": "counseling and mental health",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career plan",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career plan",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Mental health support inspired and enabled Caroline's career choice in counseling, suggesting it played a key role in her pursuit of this career path.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?
Gold answer: Likely no
Model response: Mental health support inspired and enabled Caroline's career choice in counseling, suggesting it played a key role in her pursuit of this career path.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q14",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?",
 "gold": "Likely no",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1741,
 "retrieval_ms": 5905.6,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interested in",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career transition",
   "object": "counseling career",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perceives",
   "object": "counseling work as tough",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "observed",
   "object": "counseling benefits",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "career question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "counseling details question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "motivation for career",
   "object": "helping others",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "mental health support",
   "predicate": "enabled",
   "object": "caroline career realization",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "mental health support",
   "predicate": "inspired",
   "object": "caroline career choice",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career goal",
   "object": "support those with similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career aspiration",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career motivation",
   "object": "support those with similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "would be great counselor",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks advice",
   "object": "career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career choice reason",
   "object": "support those with similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "states interest",
   "object": "keen on counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career aspiration",
   "object": "counseling and mental health",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career plan",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career plan",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interested in\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career transition\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling career\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perceives\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling work as tough\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observed\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling benefits\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"career question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling details question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivation for career\",\n  \"object\": \"helping others\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health jobs\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"mental health support\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enabled\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline career realization\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"mental health support\",\n  \"predicate\": \"inspired\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline career choice\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career goal\",\n  \"object\": \"support those with similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career aspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career motivation\",\n  \"object\": \"support those with similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"would be great counselor\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice\",\n  \"object\": \"career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career choice reason\",\n  \"object\": \"support those with similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"states interest\",\n  \"object\": \"keen on counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career aspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career plan\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career plan\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Mental health support inspired and enabled Caroline's career choice in counseling, suggesting it played a key role in her pursuit of this career path.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Caroline still want to pursue counseling as a career if she hadn't received support growing up?\nGold answer: Likely no\nModel response: Mental health support inspired and enabled Caroline's career choice in counseling, suggesting it played a key role in her pursuit of this career path.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q2open-domain✗ wrong1697 ctx tok12051 ms recall

Q: What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?

gold: Psychology, counseling certification

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · interested in · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · interested in · mental health work
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · mental health work
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · career question
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has occupation · student
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · aims to · promote understanding
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · values · unique paths
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · values · individual paths
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · unique paths exist
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline mentor · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health jobs
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks to make difference · society
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · continue education
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future plan · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · believes · would be great counselor
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks advice · career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks validation · career aspirations
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares future goals · education and career
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · states plan · check out career options
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · views life as · ongoing adventure of learning growing
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · believes in · community
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · excitement for · learning advocacy
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline as mother · type · future role
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interested in",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interested in",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "career question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has occupation",
  "object": "student",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "aims to",
  "object": "promote understanding",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "unique paths",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "individual paths",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "unique paths exist",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline mentor",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks to make difference",
  "object": "society",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "continue education",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "would be great counselor",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks advice",
  "object": "career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks validation",
  "object": "career aspirations",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares future goals",
  "object": "education and career",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "states plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "views life as",
  "object": "ongoing adventure of learning growing",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excitement for",
  "object": "learning advocacy",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline as mother",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "future role",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Counseling and mental health work.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?
Gold answer: Psychology, counseling certification
Model response: Counseling and mental health work.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q2",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?",
 "gold": "Psychology, counseling certification",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1697,
 "retrieval_ms": 12051,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interested in",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interested in",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "career question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has occupation",
   "object": "student",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "aims to",
   "object": "promote understanding",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "unique paths",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "individual paths",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "unique paths exist",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline mentor",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks to make difference",
   "object": "society",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "continue education",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "would be great counselor",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks advice",
   "object": "career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks validation",
   "object": "career aspirations",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares future goals",
   "object": "education and career",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "states plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "views life as",
   "object": "ongoing adventure of learning growing",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excitement for",
   "object": "learning advocacy",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline as mother",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "future role",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interested in\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interested in\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"career question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has occupation\",\n  \"object\": \"student\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"aims to\",\n  \"object\": \"promote understanding\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"unique paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"individual paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"unique paths exist\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline mentor\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health jobs\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks to make difference\",\n  \"object\": \"society\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue education\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"would be great counselor\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice\",\n  \"object\": \"career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks validation\",\n  \"object\": \"career aspirations\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares future goals\",\n  \"object\": \"education and career\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"states plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views life as\",\n  \"object\": \"ongoing adventure of learning growing\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excitement for\",\n  \"object\": \"learning advocacy\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"future role\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Counseling and mental health work.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What fields would Caroline be likely to pursue in her educaton?\nGold answer: Psychology, counseling certification\nModel response: Counseling and mental health work.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q22open-domain✗ wrong1690 ctx tok5681 ms recall

Q: Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?

gold: Yes, since she collects classic children's books

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · might try · pottery
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · creating · library
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · anticipation · reading to children
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · anticipation · opening childrens minds
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] library · label · caroline's future children's library
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · shared image · image bookcase
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines grandma · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] carolines friend · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · shares image · image of bookshelf 1
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] bookshelf with books · type · furniture
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · shares image · image of bookshelf 2
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · other objects question
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · wants · to help others
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes in · sharing stories
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · wants to provide · home for kids
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · considers · gift
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about novelty · caroline
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · loves · reading
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · considers reading important · personal journey
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · considers · books as guides
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · considers · books as motivation
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · considers · books as self discovery tool
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · values · books as guides
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · values · books for self discovery
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · reading book recommended by · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · additional source · authenticity
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · adopt children
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to give · loving home to kids who need it
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · type · friend
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · describes · children
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "might try",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "creating",
  "object": "library",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "anticipation",
  "object": "reading to children",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "anticipation",
  "object": "opening childrens minds",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "library",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline's future children's library",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared image",
  "object": "image bookcase",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines grandma",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "carolines friend",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares image",
  "object": "image of bookshelf 1",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "bookshelf with books",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "furniture",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares image",
  "object": "image of bookshelf 2",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "other objects question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants",
  "object": "to help others",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "sharing stories",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to provide",
  "object": "home for kids",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "gift",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about novelty",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "loves",
  "object": "reading",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "considers reading important",
  "object": "personal journey",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "books as guides",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "books as motivation",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "books as self discovery tool",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "books as guides",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "books for self discovery",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "reading book recommended by",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "additional source",
  "object": "authenticity",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "adopt children",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to give",
  "object": "loving home to kids who need it",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "friend",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "children",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Not enough information.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?
Gold answer: Yes, since she collects classic children's books
Model response: Not enough information.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q22",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?",
 "gold": "Yes, since she collects classic children's books",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1690,
 "retrieval_ms": 5680.8,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "might try",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "creating",
   "object": "library",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "anticipation",
   "object": "reading to children",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "anticipation",
   "object": "opening childrens minds",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "library",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline's future children's library",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image bookcase",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines grandma",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "carolines friend",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares image",
   "object": "image of bookshelf 1",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "bookshelf with books",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "furniture",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares image",
   "object": "image of bookshelf 2",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "other objects question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants",
   "object": "to help others",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "sharing stories",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to provide",
   "object": "home for kids",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "gift",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about novelty",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "loves",
   "object": "reading",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "considers reading important",
   "object": "personal journey",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "books as guides",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "books as motivation",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "books as self discovery tool",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "books as guides",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "books for self discovery",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "reading book recommended by",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "additional source",
   "object": "authenticity",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "adopt children",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to give",
   "object": "loving home to kids who need it",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "friend",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "children",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"might try\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"creating\",\n  \"object\": \"library\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"anticipation\",\n  \"object\": \"reading to children\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"anticipation\",\n  \"object\": \"opening childrens minds\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"library\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline's future children's library\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared image\",\n  \"object\": \"image bookcase\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines grandma\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"carolines friend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares image\",\n  \"object\": \"image of bookshelf 1\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"bookshelf with books\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"furniture\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares image\",\n  \"object\": \"image of bookshelf 2\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"other objects question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants\",\n  \"object\": \"to help others\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to provide\",\n  \"object\": \"home for kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"gift\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about novelty\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"loves\",\n  \"object\": \"reading\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers reading important\",\n  \"object\": \"personal journey\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"books as guides\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"books as motivation\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"books as self discovery tool\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"books as guides\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"books for self discovery\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reading book recommended by\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"additional source\",\n  \"object\": \"authenticity\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to give\",\n  \"object\": \"loving home to kids who need it\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"friend\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"children\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Not enough information.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Caroline likely have Dr. Seuss books on her bookshelf?\nGold answer: Yes, since she collects classic children's books\nModel response: Not enough information.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q27open-domain✗ wrong1701 ctx tok6213 ms recall

Q: Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?

gold: LIkely no; though she likes reading, she wants to be a counselor

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · interested in · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · interested in · mental health work
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · counseling
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · has career interest · mental health work
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · answers · career question
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · motivation for career · helping others
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks career · counseling and mental health jobs
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · continue education
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · counseling
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career interest · mental health
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career goal · support those with similar issues
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future plan · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · career aspiration · working in mental health
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks advice · career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · seeks validation · career aspirations
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares future goals · education and career
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · states plan · check out career options
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · wants to · make difference
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · career plan · counseling
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline as mother · type · future role
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · commits to · making effort
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · shares · personal goals
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interested in",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "interested in",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has career interest",
  "object": "mental health work",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "answers",
  "object": "career question",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "motivation for career",
  "object": "helping others",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks career",
  "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "continue education",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career interest",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career goal",
  "object": "support those with similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career aspiration",
  "object": "working in mental health",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks advice",
  "object": "career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks validation",
  "object": "career aspirations",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares future goals",
  "object": "education and career",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "states plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "make difference",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "career plan",
  "object": "counseling",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline as mother",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "future role",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commits to",
  "object": "making effort",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares",
  "object": "personal goals",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Not enough information.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?
Gold answer: LIkely no; though she likes reading, she wants to be a counselor
Model response: Not enough information.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q27",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?",
 "gold": "LIkely no; though she likes reading, she wants to be a counselor",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1701,
 "retrieval_ms": 6212.5,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interested in",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "interested in",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has career interest",
   "object": "mental health work",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "answers",
   "object": "career question",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "motivation for career",
   "object": "helping others",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks career",
   "object": "counseling and mental health jobs",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "continue education",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career interest",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career goal",
   "object": "support those with similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career aspiration",
   "object": "working in mental health",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks advice",
   "object": "career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks validation",
   "object": "career aspirations",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares future goals",
   "object": "education and career",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "states plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "make difference",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "career plan",
   "object": "counseling",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline as mother",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "future role",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commits to",
   "object": "making effort",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares",
   "object": "personal goals",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interested in\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"interested in\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health work\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"answers\",\n  \"object\": \"career question\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivation for career\",\n  \"object\": \"helping others\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks career\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling and mental health jobs\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue education\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career interest\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career goal\",\n  \"object\": \"support those with similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career aspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"working in mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice\",\n  \"object\": \"career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks validation\",\n  \"object\": \"career aspirations\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares future goals\",\n  \"object\": \"education and career\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"states plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"make difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"career plan\",\n  \"object\": \"counseling\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"future role\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commits to\",\n  \"object\": \"making effort\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares\",\n  \"object\": \"personal goals\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Not enough information.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Caroline pursue writing as a career option?\nGold answer: LIkely no; though she likes reading, she wants to be a counselor\nModel response: Not enough information.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q30open-domain✓ correct1637 ctx tok5217 ms recall

Q: Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?

gold: Likely no, she does not refer to herself as part of it

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] lgbtq community · type · community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · advocates for · lgbtq community
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] lgbtq community · type · community
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · lgbtq support group attendance
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about effect · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked for details · lgbtq support group attendance
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about inspiring stories · lgbtq support group attendance
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · requested details about · connected lgbtq activists
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · acknowledges · lgbtq rights progress
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · acknowledged · progress in lgbtq rights
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · believes in · community creation
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · type · person
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] lgbtq community · type · community
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq community",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "advocates for",
  "object": "lgbtq community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq community",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about effect",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked for details",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about inspiring stories",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "requested details about",
  "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "acknowledges",
  "object": "lgbtq rights progress",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "acknowledged",
  "object": "progress in lgbtq rights",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "community creation",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "lgbtq community",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Not enough information. The memories show Melanie's involvement with and support for the LGBTQ community (attending support groups, asking about rights progress), but don't explicitly state her own sexual orientation or gender identity, which would be needed to determine if she's a member herself.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?
Gold answer: Likely no, she does not refer to herself as part of it
Model response: Not enough information. The memories show Melanie's involvement with and support for the LGBTQ community (attending support groups, asking about rights progress), but don't explicitly state her own sexual orientation or gender identity, which would be needed to determine if she's a member herself.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q30",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?",
 "gold": "Likely no, she does not refer to herself as part of it",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1637,
 "retrieval_ms": 5216.7,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq community",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "advocates for",
   "object": "lgbtq community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq community",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about effect",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked for details",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about inspiring stories",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "requested details about",
   "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "acknowledges",
   "object": "lgbtq rights progress",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "acknowledged",
   "object": "progress in lgbtq rights",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "community creation",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "lgbtq community",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"advocates for\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about effect\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked for details\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about inspiring stories\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"requested details about\",\n  \"object\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"acknowledges\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq rights progress\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"acknowledged\",\n  \"object\": \"progress in lgbtq rights\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"community creation\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"lgbtq community\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Not enough information. The memories show Melanie's involvement with and support for the LGBTQ community (attending support groups, asking about rights progress), but don't explicitly state her own sexual orientation or gender identity, which would be needed to determine if she's a member herself.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Melanie be considered a member of the LGBTQ community?\nGold answer: Likely no, she does not refer to herself as part of it\nModel response: Not enough information. The memories show Melanie's involvement with and support for the LGBTQ community (attending support groups, asking about rights progress), but don't explicitly state her own sexual orientation or gender identity, which would be needed to determine if she's a member herself.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q42open-domain✓ correct1690 ctx tok6983 ms recall

Q: Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?

gold: National park; she likes the outdoors

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · asks · future plans
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · asks · idea inspiration
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · learning view · learning new about nature
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · has activity · forest exploration
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · seeks · love and motivation
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · different paths
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · wants to · tackle challenges together
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · believes · different paths exist
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] park visit · has participant · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] park visit · has participant · melanie s kids
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · asked about participation in · events
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · seeks advice from · caroline
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · agrees to · special trip summer
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · considers · art
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · will plan · special activity
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · visited · park
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · observes · outdoor enjoyment
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · asks · next time plans
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] park visit · participant · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] park visit · participant · melanie kids
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · asks about · memorable aspects
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · beach visit
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · asks question · question about activities
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · seeks similar experience · therapeutic activity
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · future goal · discovering potential
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · plans · camping trip
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · asks · question about summer plans
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · enjoys · nature
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · describes · nature experience
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · asked about · caroline weekend activities
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · appreciates · friendship
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has children · melanie children
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · took break from · pottery
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · had previous conversation with · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · family moments
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · uses clarinet · self expression

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "future plans",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "idea inspiration",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "learning view",
  "object": "learning new about nature",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has activity",
  "object": "forest exploration",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "seeks",
  "object": "love and motivation",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "different paths",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "tackle challenges together",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "different paths exist",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "park visit",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "park visit",
  "predicate": "has participant",
  "object": "melanie s kids",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about participation in",
  "object": "events",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "seeks advice from",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "agrees to",
  "object": "special trip summer",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "art",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "will plan",
  "object": "special activity",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "visited",
  "object": "park",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "observes",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "next time plans",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "park visit",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "park visit",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie kids",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks about",
  "object": "memorable aspects",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "beach visit",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks question",
  "object": "question about activities",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "seeks similar experience",
  "object": "therapeutic activity",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "future goal",
  "object": "discovering potential",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "plans",
  "object": "camping trip",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "question about summer plans",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "enjoys",
  "object": "nature",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "nature experience",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about",
  "object": "caroline weekend activities",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "friendship",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has children",
  "object": "melanie children",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "took break from",
  "object": "pottery",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Based on the memories, Melanie would be more interested in going to a national park. The memories show she enjoys nature, has done forest exploration, went on mountain camping trips, and plans camping trips. There's no mention of theme park interest.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?
Gold answer: National park; she likes the outdoors
Model response: Based on the memories, Melanie would be more interested in going to a national park. The memories show she enjoys nature, has done forest exploration, went on mountain camping trips, and plans camping trips. There's no mention of theme park interest.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q42",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?",
 "gold": "National park; she likes the outdoors",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1690,
 "retrieval_ms": 6983.4,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "future plans",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "idea inspiration",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "learning view",
   "object": "learning new about nature",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has activity",
   "object": "forest exploration",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "seeks",
   "object": "love and motivation",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "different paths",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "tackle challenges together",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "different paths exist",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "park visit",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "park visit",
   "predicate": "has participant",
   "object": "melanie s kids",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about participation in",
   "object": "events",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "seeks advice from",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "agrees to",
   "object": "special trip summer",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "art",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "will plan",
   "object": "special activity",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "visited",
   "object": "park",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "observes",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "next time plans",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "park visit",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "park visit",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie kids",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks about",
   "object": "memorable aspects",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "beach visit",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks question",
   "object": "question about activities",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "seeks similar experience",
   "object": "therapeutic activity",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "future goal",
   "object": "discovering potential",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "plans",
   "object": "camping trip",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "question about summer plans",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "enjoys",
   "object": "nature",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "nature experience",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about",
   "object": "caroline weekend activities",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "friendship",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has children",
   "object": "melanie children",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "took break from",
   "object": "pottery",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "had previous conversation with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "family moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses clarinet",
   "object": "self expression",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"future plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"idea inspiration\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"learning view\",\n  \"object\": \"learning new about nature\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has activity\",\n  \"object\": \"forest exploration\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks\",\n  \"object\": \"love and motivation\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"different paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"tackle challenges together\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"different paths exist\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"park visit\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"park visit\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie s kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about participation in\",\n  \"object\": \"events\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice from\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"agrees to\",\n  \"object\": \"special trip summer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"art\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"will plan\",\n  \"object\": \"special activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"visited\",\n  \"object\": \"park\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observes\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"next time plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"park visit\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"park visit\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie kids\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks about\",\n  \"object\": \"memorable aspects\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"beach visit\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks question\",\n  \"object\": \"question about activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks similar experience\",\n  \"object\": \"therapeutic activity\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future goal\",\n  \"object\": \"discovering potential\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"plans\",\n  \"object\": \"camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"question about summer plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"enjoys\",\n  \"object\": \"nature\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"nature experience\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline weekend activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"friendship\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has children\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie children\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"took break from\",\n  \"object\": \"pottery\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"had previous conversation with\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Based on the memories, Melanie would be more interested in going to a national park. The memories show she enjoys nature, has done forest exploration, went on mountain camping trips, and plans camping trips. There's no mention of theme park interest.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Melanie be more interested in going to a national park or a theme park?\nGold answer: National park; she likes the outdoors\nModel response: Based on the memories, Melanie would be more interested in going to a national park. The memories show she enjoys nature, has done forest exploration, went on mountain camping trips, and plans camping trips. There's no mention of theme park interest.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q46open-domain✓ correct1666 ctx tok6589 ms recall

Q: Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?

gold: Yes, she is supportive

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · joined community · transgender community
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] transgender community · type · community
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] melanie · asks about · transition support
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · received · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · promotes · love and acceptance
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · wants · to help others
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · aims to · create acceptance
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · values · mutual support
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · lgbtq support group attendance
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about effect · lgbtq support group
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked for details · lgbtq support group attendance
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · asked about inspiring stories · lgbtq support group attendance
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · requested details about · connected lgbtq activists
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · wants to help · trans rights
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · acknowledges · lgbtq rights progress
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · acknowledged · progress in lgbtq rights
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] friendship · participant · melanie
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · offer · support
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · believes in · community creation
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · believes in · mutual support
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · type · person
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · type · person
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "joined community",
  "object": "transgender community",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "transgender community",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks about",
  "object": "transition support",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "received",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "promotes",
  "object": "love and acceptance",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "wants",
  "object": "to help others",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "aims to",
  "object": "create acceptance",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about effect",
  "object": "lgbtq support group",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked for details",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about inspiring stories",
  "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "requested details about",
  "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to help",
  "object": "trans rights",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "acknowledges",
  "object": "lgbtq rights progress",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "acknowledged",
  "object": "progress in lgbtq rights",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "friendship",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "offer",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "community creation",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Yes. Melanie’s recorded actions and beliefs align with allyship: she promotes love and acceptance, wants to help others, aims to create acceptance, values mutual support, asks about transition support, expresses admiration for and seeks details about LGBTQ support groups and activists, acknowledges LGBTQ rights progress, offers support, and believes in community creation.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?
Gold answer: Yes, she is supportive
Model response: Yes. Melanie’s recorded actions and beliefs align with allyship: she promotes love and acceptance, wants to help others, aims to create acceptance, values mutual support, asks about transition support, expresses admiration for and seeks details about LGBTQ support groups and activists, acknowledges LGBTQ rights progress, offers support, and believes in community creation.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q46",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?",
 "gold": "Yes, she is supportive",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1666,
 "retrieval_ms": 6588.8,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "joined community",
   "object": "transgender community",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "transgender community",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks about",
   "object": "transition support",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "received",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "promotes",
   "object": "love and acceptance",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "wants",
   "object": "to help others",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "aims to",
   "object": "create acceptance",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about effect",
   "object": "lgbtq support group",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked for details",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about inspiring stories",
   "object": "lgbtq support group attendance",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "requested details about",
   "object": "connected lgbtq activists",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to help",
   "object": "trans rights",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "acknowledges",
   "object": "lgbtq rights progress",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "acknowledged",
   "object": "progress in lgbtq rights",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "friendship",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "offer",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "community creation",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"joined community\",\n  \"object\": \"transgender community\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"transgender community\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks about\",\n  \"object\": \"transition support\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"promotes\",\n  \"object\": \"love and acceptance\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants\",\n  \"object\": \"to help others\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"aims to\",\n  \"object\": \"create acceptance\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about effect\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked for details\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about inspiring stories\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq support group attendance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"requested details about\",\n  \"object\": \"connected lgbtq activists\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to help\",\n  \"object\": \"trans rights\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"acknowledges\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq rights progress\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"acknowledged\",\n  \"object\": \"progress in lgbtq rights\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"friendship\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"offer\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"community creation\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Yes. Melanie’s recorded actions and beliefs align with allyship: she promotes love and acceptance, wants to help others, aims to create acceptance, values mutual support, asks about transition support, expresses admiration for and seeks details about LGBTQ support groups and activists, acknowledges LGBTQ rights progress, offers support, and believes in community creation.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Would Melanie be considered an ally to the transgender community?\nGold answer: Yes, she is supportive\nModel response: Yes. Melanie’s recorded actions and beliefs align with allyship: she promotes love and acceptance, wants to help others, aims to create acceptance, values mutual support, asks about transition support, expresses admiration for and seeks details about LGBTQ support groups and activists, acknowledges LGBTQ rights progress, offers support, and believes in community creation.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q50open-domain✓ correct1594 ctx tok5775 ms recall

Q: What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?

gold: Liberal

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] caroline · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · type · person
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · advocate
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · seeks to make difference · society
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · believes in · community
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · wants to · make difference
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · has belief · activism impact
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline as mother · type · future role
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · type · person
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · evaluation · special
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · communication style · open
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting red shirt

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "advocate",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks to make difference",
  "object": "society",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "community",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "make difference",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has belief",
  "object": "activism impact",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline as mother",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "future role",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "reveals motivation",
  "object": "support similar issues",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Based on the memories, Caroline's political leaning is likely progressive or left-leaning. This inference comes from her role as an advocate, attendance at an LGBTQ conference, belief in the impact of activism, and motivation to support similar social issues.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?
Gold answer: Liberal
Model response: Based on the memories, Caroline's political leaning is likely progressive or left-leaning. This inference comes from her role as an advocate, attendance at an LGBTQ conference, belief in the impact of activism, and motivation to support similar social issues.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q50",
 "category": 3,
 "question": "What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?",
 "gold": "Liberal",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1594,
 "retrieval_ms": 5775.4,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "advocate",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks to make difference",
   "object": "society",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "community",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "make difference",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has belief",
   "object": "activism impact",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline as mother",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "future role",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "evaluation",
   "object": "special",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "communication style",
   "object": "open",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting red shirt",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"advocate\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks to make difference\",\n  \"object\": \"society\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"community\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"make difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has belief\",\n  \"object\": \"activism impact\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"future role\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"reveals motivation\",\n  \"object\": \"support similar issues\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Based on the memories, Caroline's political leaning is likely progressive or left-leaning. This inference comes from her role as an advocate, attendance at an LGBTQ conference, belief in the impact of activism, and motivation to support similar social issues.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What would Caroline's political leaning likely be?\nGold answer: Liberal\nModel response: Based on the memories, Caroline's political leaning is likely progressive or left-leaning. This inference comes from her role as an advocate, attendance at an LGBTQ conference, belief in the impact of activism, and motivation to support similar social issues.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q82single-hop✓ correct1754 ctx tok5568 ms recall

Q: What did the charity race raise awareness for?

gold: mental health

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] volunteering at shelter · emotional impact · great to make difference
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] volunteering at shelter · impact · awareness of neglect
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · volunteering impact · making difference
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · volunteering inspiration · making difference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] volunteering · type · event
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] pride parade last weekend · associated cause · equality
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · benefit for · melanie
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · provides benefit · de stress
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · provides benefit · clear mind
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · provides benefit · mental health improvement
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · boosts · mood
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · helps · mental health
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] pride parade · has purpose · awareness raising
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] pride parade · has effect · motivation
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] pride parade experience · caused in · desire to help others
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] pride parade experience · resulted in · community awareness
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · type · event
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · type · race
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · type · fundraising event
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · has purpose · mental health awareness
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · participant · melanie
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · occurred on · 2023 05 20
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · description · rewarding
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · participated in · charity race mental health
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · caused · melanie thinking about mental health care
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · occurred relative · last saturday
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · described as · really rewarding
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · raised awareness for · mental health
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] advocacy event · has atmosphere · love
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] advocacy event · has atmosphere · support
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What did the charity race raise awareness for?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
  "predicate": "emotional impact",
  "object": "great to make difference",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
  "predicate": "impact",
  "object": "awareness of neglect",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "volunteering impact",
  "object": "making difference",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "volunteering inspiration",
  "object": "making difference",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "volunteering",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "event",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "pride parade last weekend",
  "predicate": "associated cause",
  "object": "equality",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "benefit for",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "provides benefit",
  "object": "de stress",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "provides benefit",
  "object": "clear mind",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "provides benefit",
  "object": "mental health improvement",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "boosts",
  "object": "mood",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "helps",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "pride parade",
  "predicate": "has purpose",
  "object": "awareness raising",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "pride parade",
  "predicate": "has effect",
  "object": "motivation",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "pride parade experience",
  "predicate": "caused in",
  "object": "desire to help others",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "pride parade experience",
  "predicate": "resulted in",
  "object": "community awareness",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "event",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "race",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "fundraising event",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "has purpose",
  "object": "mental health awareness",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "occurred on",
  "object": "2023 05 20",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "description",
  "object": "rewarding",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "charity race mental health",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "caused",
  "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "occurred relative",
  "object": "last saturday",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "described as",
  "object": "really rewarding",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "raised awareness for",
  "object": "mental health",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "advocacy event",
  "predicate": "has atmosphere",
  "object": "love",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "advocacy event",
  "predicate": "has atmosphere",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Mental health

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What did the charity race raise awareness for?
Gold answer: mental health
Model response: Mental health

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q82",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What did the charity race raise awareness for?",
 "gold": "mental health",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1754,
 "retrieval_ms": 5567.9,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
   "predicate": "emotional impact",
   "object": "great to make difference",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "volunteering at shelter",
   "predicate": "impact",
   "object": "awareness of neglect",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "volunteering impact",
   "object": "making difference",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "volunteering inspiration",
   "object": "making difference",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "volunteering",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "event",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "pride parade last weekend",
   "predicate": "associated cause",
   "object": "equality",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "benefit for",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "provides benefit",
   "object": "de stress",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "provides benefit",
   "object": "clear mind",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "provides benefit",
   "object": "mental health improvement",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "boosts",
   "object": "mood",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "helps",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "pride parade",
   "predicate": "has purpose",
   "object": "awareness raising",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "pride parade",
   "predicate": "has effect",
   "object": "motivation",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "pride parade experience",
   "predicate": "caused in",
   "object": "desire to help others",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "pride parade experience",
   "predicate": "resulted in",
   "object": "community awareness",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "event",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "race",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "fundraising event",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "has purpose",
   "object": "mental health awareness",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "occurred on",
   "object": "2023 05 20",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "description",
   "object": "rewarding",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "charity race mental health",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "caused",
   "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "occurred relative",
   "object": "last saturday",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "described as",
   "object": "really rewarding",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "raised awareness for",
   "object": "mental health",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "advocacy event",
   "predicate": "has atmosphere",
   "object": "love",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "advocacy event",
   "predicate": "has atmosphere",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What did the charity race raise awareness for?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"volunteering at shelter\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional impact\",\n  \"object\": \"great to make difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"volunteering at shelter\",\n  \"predicate\": \"impact\",\n  \"object\": \"awareness of neglect\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteering impact\",\n  \"object\": \"making difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"volunteering inspiration\",\n  \"object\": \"making difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"volunteering\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"event\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"pride parade last weekend\",\n  \"predicate\": \"associated cause\",\n  \"object\": \"equality\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"benefit for\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides benefit\",\n  \"object\": \"de stress\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides benefit\",\n  \"object\": \"clear mind\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides benefit\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health improvement\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"boosts\",\n  \"object\": \"mood\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"helps\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"pride parade\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has purpose\",\n  \"object\": \"awareness raising\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"pride parade\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has effect\",\n  \"object\": \"motivation\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"pride parade experience\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused in\",\n  \"object\": \"desire to help others\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"pride parade experience\",\n  \"predicate\": \"resulted in\",\n  \"object\": \"community awareness\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"event\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"race\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"fundraising event\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has purpose\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health awareness\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occurred on\",\n  \"object\": \"2023 05 20\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"description\",\n  \"object\": \"rewarding\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie thinking about mental health care\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"occurred relative\",\n  \"object\": \"last saturday\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"described as\",\n  \"object\": \"really rewarding\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"raised awareness for\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"advocacy event\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has atmosphere\",\n  \"object\": \"love\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"advocacy event\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has atmosphere\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Mental health",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What did the charity race raise awareness for?\nGold answer: mental health\nModel response: Mental health\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q83single-hop✓ correct1665 ctx tok5839 ms recall

Q: What did Melanie realize after the charity race?

gold: self-care is important

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie family · supported · melanie
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · motivated by · melanie family
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has goal · make a difference
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · faces · challenges
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · received · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · provides · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has · hope
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · aims to · create hope
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · recognizes · vulnerable moments
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · recognizes · importance of vulnerable moments
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · believes · vulnerable moments enable understanding
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · recognized · positive effect on others
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · felt · proud
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · felt · motivated
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · has goal · create hope
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · values · mutual support
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] running · benefit for · melanie
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · commits to · continue running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · encouraged · melanie to continue running
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · committed to · continue running
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · responsibility · work
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · decoded as · brave
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · believes · will help people
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · attributed motivation · catch eye
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · commented on · volunteering
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · believes in · mutual support
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · participant · melanie
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · participated in · charity race mental health
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · does · running
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] charity race mental health · caused · melanie thinking about mental health care
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What did Melanie realize after the charity race?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie family",
  "predicate": "supported",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "motivated by",
  "object": "melanie family",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has goal",
  "object": "make a difference",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "faces",
  "object": "challenges",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "received",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "provides",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has",
  "object": "hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "aims to",
  "object": "create hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "recognizes",
  "object": "vulnerable moments",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "recognizes",
  "object": "importance of vulnerable moments",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "vulnerable moments enable understanding",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "recognized",
  "object": "positive effect on others",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "felt",
  "object": "proud",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "felt",
  "object": "motivated",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has goal",
  "object": "create hope",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "running",
  "predicate": "benefit for",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "commits to",
  "object": "continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "encouraged",
  "object": "melanie to continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "committed to",
  "object": "continue running",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "responsibility",
  "object": "work",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "decoded as",
  "object": "brave",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "will help people",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "attributed motivation",
  "object": "catch eye",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "volunteering",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "participant",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "participated in",
  "object": "charity race mental health",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "does",
  "object": "running",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "charity race mental health",
  "predicate": "caused",
  "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

The charity race caused Melanie to think about mental health care.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What did Melanie realize after the charity race?
Gold answer: self-care is important
Model response: The charity race caused Melanie to think about mental health care.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q83",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What did Melanie realize after the charity race?",
 "gold": "self-care is important",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1665,
 "retrieval_ms": 5839.4,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie family",
   "predicate": "supported",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "motivated by",
   "object": "melanie family",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has goal",
   "object": "make a difference",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "faces",
   "object": "challenges",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "received",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "provides",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has",
   "object": "hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "aims to",
   "object": "create hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "recognizes",
   "object": "vulnerable moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "recognizes",
   "object": "importance of vulnerable moments",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "vulnerable moments enable understanding",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "recognized",
   "object": "positive effect on others",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "felt",
   "object": "proud",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "felt",
   "object": "motivated",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has goal",
   "object": "create hope",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "running",
   "predicate": "benefit for",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "commits to",
   "object": "continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "encouraged",
   "object": "melanie to continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "committed to",
   "object": "continue running",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "responsibility",
   "object": "work",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "decoded as",
   "object": "brave",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "will help people",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributed motivation",
   "object": "catch eye",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "volunteering",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "participant",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "participated in",
   "object": "charity race mental health",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "does",
   "object": "running",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "charity race mental health",
   "predicate": "caused",
   "object": "melanie thinking about mental health care",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What did Melanie realize after the charity race?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"predicate\": \"supported\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"motivated by\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie family\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has goal\",\n  \"object\": \"make a difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"faces\",\n  \"object\": \"challenges\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has\",\n  \"object\": \"hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"aims to\",\n  \"object\": \"create hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"recognizes\",\n  \"object\": \"vulnerable moments\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"recognizes\",\n  \"object\": \"importance of vulnerable moments\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"vulnerable moments enable understanding\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"recognized\",\n  \"object\": \"positive effect on others\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"felt\",\n  \"object\": \"proud\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"felt\",\n  \"object\": \"motivated\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has goal\",\n  \"object\": \"create hope\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"running\",\n  \"predicate\": \"benefit for\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commits to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"encouraged\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie to continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"committed to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue running\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responsibility\",\n  \"object\": \"work\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"decoded as\",\n  \"object\": \"brave\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"will help people\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attributed motivation\",\n  \"object\": \"catch eye\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"volunteering\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participant\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"participated in\",\n  \"object\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"does\",\n  \"object\": \"running\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"charity race mental health\",\n  \"predicate\": \"caused\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie thinking about mental health care\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "The charity race caused Melanie to think about mental health care.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What did Melanie realize after the charity race?\nGold answer: self-care is important\nModel response: The charity race caused Melanie to think about mental health care.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q84single-hop✗ wrong1693 ctx tok6095 ms recall

Q: How does Melanie prioritize self-care?

gold: by carving out some me-time each day for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · supports · caroline true self
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · provides · support
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · wants · to help others
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] melanie · values · individual paths
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · observes · found true self helping others
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · described as · helpful
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · encourages · melanie to prioritize mental health
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · experiences · mental health improvement
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · responsibility · work
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · agreement · taking care of ourselves is vital
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · states · taking care of ourselves is vital
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · provides support · empathy and understanding
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · believes · will help people
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · provides advice to · melanie
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · advice · take care of yourself
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · question · what else helps
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · closing · take care
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · believes in · mutual support
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · shares personal experience · first steps
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · views activity as · therapy
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · thought about · mental health care
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · believes · self care is important
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · is on journey · self care
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · describes · caring heart
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · cares for better when · self care practiced
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · agrees with · melanie on self care importance
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · attributes · caring heart to caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · describes · self care is a journey
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · realized · self care importance
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] melanie · uses · family as support
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: How does Melanie prioritize self-care?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "supports",
  "object": "caroline true self",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "provides",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "wants",
  "object": "to help others",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "individual paths",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "observes",
  "object": "found true self helping others",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "described as",
  "object": "helpful",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "encourages",
  "object": "melanie to prioritize mental health",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "experiences",
  "object": "mental health improvement",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "responsibility",
  "object": "work",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "agreement",
  "object": "taking care of ourselves is vital",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "states",
  "object": "taking care of ourselves is vital",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "provides support",
  "object": "empathy and understanding",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "will help people",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "provides advice to",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "advice",
  "object": "take care of yourself",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "question",
  "object": "what else helps",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "closing",
  "object": "take care",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "mutual support",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "shares personal experience",
  "object": "first steps",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "views activity as",
  "object": "therapy",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "thought about",
  "object": "mental health care",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "self care is important",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "is on journey",
  "object": "self care",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "caring heart",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "cares for better when",
  "object": "self care practiced",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "agrees with",
  "object": "melanie on self care importance",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "attributes",
  "object": "caring heart to caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "self care is a journey",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "realized",
  "object": "self care importance",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "uses",
  "object": "family as support",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Melanie prioritizes self-care by: - Believing self-care is important and on a journey - Using family as support - Going camping (mountain camping trip) - Practicing self-care regularly, which helps her care better - Focusing on mental health (improvement observed when encouraged)

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: How does Melanie prioritize self-care?
Gold answer: by carving out some me-time each day for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin
Model response: Melanie prioritizes self-care by:
- Believing self-care is important and on a journey
- Using family as support
- Going camping (mountain camping trip)
- Practicing self-care regularly, which helps her care better
- Focusing on mental health (improvement observed when encouraged)

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

The model response does not mention carving out daily me-time for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin, which is the core of the gold answer. While it lists other self-care related points, these do not match or imply the specific daily activities and time allocation described in the gold answer. Therefore, the response is not equivalent to the gold answer. VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q84",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "How does Melanie prioritize self-care?",
 "gold": "by carving out some me-time each day for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1693,
 "retrieval_ms": 6094.9,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "supports",
   "object": "caroline true self",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "provides",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "wants",
   "object": "to help others",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "individual paths",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "observes",
   "object": "found true self helping others",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "described as",
   "object": "helpful",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "encourages",
   "object": "melanie to prioritize mental health",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "experiences",
   "object": "mental health improvement",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "responsibility",
   "object": "work",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "agreement",
   "object": "taking care of ourselves is vital",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "states",
   "object": "taking care of ourselves is vital",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "provides support",
   "object": "empathy and understanding",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "will help people",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "provides advice to",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "advice",
   "object": "take care of yourself",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "question",
   "object": "what else helps",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "closing",
   "object": "take care",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "mutual support",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "shares personal experience",
   "object": "first steps",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "views activity as",
   "object": "therapy",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "thought about",
   "object": "mental health care",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "self care is important",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "is on journey",
   "object": "self care",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "caring heart",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "cares for better when",
   "object": "self care practiced",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "agrees with",
   "object": "melanie on self care importance",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes",
   "object": "caring heart to caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "self care is a journey",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "realized",
   "object": "self care importance",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "uses",
   "object": "family as support",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: How does Melanie prioritize self-care?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"supports\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline true self\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants\",\n  \"object\": \"to help others\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"individual paths\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"observes\",\n  \"object\": \"found true self helping others\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"described as\",\n  \"object\": \"helpful\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"encourages\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie to prioritize mental health\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"experiences\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health improvement\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responsibility\",\n  \"object\": \"work\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"agreement\",\n  \"object\": \"taking care of ourselves is vital\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"states\",\n  \"object\": \"taking care of ourselves is vital\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides support\",\n  \"object\": \"empathy and understanding\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"will help people\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides advice to\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"advice\",\n  \"object\": \"take care of yourself\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"question\",\n  \"object\": \"what else helps\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"closing\",\n  \"object\": \"take care\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"mutual support\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares personal experience\",\n  \"object\": \"first steps\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views activity as\",\n  \"object\": \"therapy\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"thought about\",\n  \"object\": \"mental health care\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"self care is important\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is on journey\",\n  \"object\": \"self care\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"caring heart\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"cares for better when\",\n  \"object\": \"self care practiced\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"agrees with\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie on self care importance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attributes\",\n  \"object\": \"caring heart to caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"self care is a journey\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"realized\",\n  \"object\": \"self care importance\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"uses\",\n  \"object\": \"family as support\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Melanie prioritizes self-care by:\n- Believing self-care is important and on a journey\n- Using family as support\n- Going camping (mountain camping trip)\n- Practicing self-care regularly, which helps her care better\n- Focusing on mental health (improvement observed when encouraged)",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: How does Melanie prioritize self-care?\nGold answer: by carving out some me-time each day for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin\nModel response: Melanie prioritizes self-care by:\n- Believing self-care is important and on a journey\n- Using family as support\n- Going camping (mountain camping trip)\n- Practicing self-care regularly, which helps her care better\n- Focusing on mental health (improvement observed when encouraged)\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "The model response does not mention carving out daily me-time for activities like running, reading, or playing the violin, which is the core of the gold answer. While it lists other self-care related points, these do not match or imply the specific daily activities and time allocation described in the gold answer. Therefore, the response is not equivalent to the gold answer.\n\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q85single-hop✗ wrong1673 ctx tok6236 ms recall

Q: What are Caroline's plans for the summer?

gold: researching adoption agencies

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023] caroline · anticipates · future motherhood
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has goal · make a change
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · faces · challenges
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has experience · development
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · wants to · tackle challenges together
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · has role · mentee
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · moved · to new location
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · intends to · lift others up
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · continue education
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · intends to · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future plan · check out career options
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · shares future goals · education and career
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · life view · ongoing adventure
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · life is · ongoing adventure
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · proposes · special trip summer
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · life goal · becoming mom
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · wants to · make difference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · asks · what up
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] caroline · asks question · summer traditions
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · promises to · provide update
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] question about caroline plans · topic · upcoming events
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · expresses · anticipation
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · create family
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline as mother · type · future role
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · asks · question about summer plans
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · commits to · making effort
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · shares · personal goals
[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023] caroline · describes · camping
[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023] melanie · asked about · caroline weekend activities
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What are Caroline's plans for the summer?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "anticipates",
  "object": "future motherhood",
  "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has goal",
  "object": "make a change",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "faces",
  "object": "challenges",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has experience",
  "object": "development",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "tackle challenges together",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has role",
  "object": "mentee",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "moved",
  "object": "to new location",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "lift others up",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "continue education",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future plan",
  "object": "check out career options",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares future goals",
  "object": "education and career",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "life view",
  "object": "ongoing adventure",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "life is",
  "object": "ongoing adventure",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "proposes",
  "object": "special trip summer",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "life goal",
  "object": "becoming mom",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "make difference",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "what up",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "asks question",
  "object": "summer traditions",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "promises to",
  "object": "provide update",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "question about caroline plans",
  "predicate": "topic",
  "object": "upcoming events",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "expresses",
  "object": "anticipation",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "create family",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline as mother",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "future role",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "question about summer plans",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commits to",
  "object": "making effort",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shares",
  "object": "personal goals",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "describes",
  "object": "camping",
  "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about",
  "object": "caroline weekend activities",
  "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline proposes a special trip for the summer.

judgeholo3.1✗ wrong

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What are Caroline's plans for the summer?
Gold answer: researching adoption agencies
Model response: Caroline proposes a special trip for the summer.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: WRONG

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q85",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What are Caroline's plans for the summer?",
 "gold": "researching adoption agencies",
 "correct": false,
 "ctx_tokens": 1673,
 "retrieval_ms": 6236.3,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "anticipates",
   "object": "future motherhood",
   "text": "[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has goal",
   "object": "make a change",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "faces",
   "object": "challenges",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has experience",
   "object": "development",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "tackle challenges together",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has role",
   "object": "mentee",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "moved",
   "object": "to new location",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "lift others up",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "continue education",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future plan",
   "object": "check out career options",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares future goals",
   "object": "education and career",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "life view",
   "object": "ongoing adventure",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "life is",
   "object": "ongoing adventure",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "proposes",
   "object": "special trip summer",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "life goal",
   "object": "becoming mom",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "make difference",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "what up",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "asks question",
   "object": "summer traditions",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "promises to",
   "object": "provide update",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "question about caroline plans",
   "predicate": "topic",
   "object": "upcoming events",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "expresses",
   "object": "anticipation",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "create family",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline as mother",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "future role",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "question about summer plans",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commits to",
   "object": "making effort",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shares",
   "object": "personal goals",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "describes",
   "object": "camping",
   "text": "[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about",
   "object": "caroline weekend activities",
   "text": "[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What are Caroline's plans for the summer?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"anticipates\",\n  \"object\": \"future motherhood\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:18 pm on 6 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has goal\",\n  \"object\": \"make a change\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"faces\",\n  \"object\": \"challenges\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has experience\",\n  \"object\": \"development\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"tackle challenges together\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has role\",\n  \"object\": \"mentee\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"moved\",\n  \"object\": \"to new location\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"lift others up\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"continue education\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future plan\",\n  \"object\": \"check out career options\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares future goals\",\n  \"object\": \"education and career\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"life view\",\n  \"object\": \"ongoing adventure\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"life is\",\n  \"object\": \"ongoing adventure\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"proposes\",\n  \"object\": \"special trip summer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"life goal\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming mom\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"make difference\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"what up\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks question\",\n  \"object\": \"summer traditions\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"promises to\",\n  \"object\": \"provide update\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"question about caroline plans\",\n  \"predicate\": \"topic\",\n  \"object\": \"upcoming events\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expresses\",\n  \"object\": \"anticipation\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"create family\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"future role\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"question about summer plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commits to\",\n  \"object\": \"making effort\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shares\",\n  \"object\": \"personal goals\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"describes\",\n  \"object\": \"camping\",\n  \"text\": \"[6:55 pm on 20 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline weekend activities\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:31 pm on 17 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline proposes a special trip for the summer.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What are Caroline's plans for the summer?\nGold answer: researching adoption agencies\nModel response: Caroline proposes a special trip for the summer.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: WRONG",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q86single-hop✓ correct1739 ctx tok5695 ms recall

Q: What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?

gold: LGBTQ+ individuals

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · intends to · adopt
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · provides · support
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · passed interviews · adoption agency interviews
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · views adoption as · way of giving back
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · wants to provide · support to others
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · sought advice about · adoption
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline adoption journey · type · process
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] supportive people · supports · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · wants to enable · people having support
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · wants to provide · support for others
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · contacted mentor for · adoption advice
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · suggests finding · adoption agency or lawyer
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has mentor · adoption mentor
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · offers help with · adoption process
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · action · applied to adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · attended · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · received help from · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · additional source · supportive people
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied this week · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · believes · ready for adoption
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · adopt children
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · chose · adoption agency lgbtq supportive
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · chose agency because · lgbtq+ support
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · seeks · adoption agency
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · responds · adoption research answer
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching multiple · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] adoption agency lgbtq supportive · attracts · caroline
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "adopt",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "provides",
  "object": "support",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "passed interviews",
  "object": "adoption agency interviews",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "views adoption as",
  "object": "way of giving back",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to provide",
  "object": "support to others",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "sought advice about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "supportive people",
  "predicate": "supports",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to enable",
  "object": "people having support",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to provide",
  "object": "support for others",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "contacted mentor for",
  "object": "adoption advice",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "suggests finding",
  "object": "adoption agency or lawyer",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has mentor",
  "object": "adoption mentor",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "offers help with",
  "object": "adoption process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "action",
  "object": "applied to adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "additional source",
  "object": "supportive people",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied this week",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "ready for adoption",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "adopt children",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "chose",
  "object": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "chose agency because",
  "object": "lgbtq+ support",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks",
  "object": "adoption agency",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "adoption research answer",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching multiple",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
  "predicate": "attracts",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

The adoption agency is LGBTQ supportive, meaning they support LGBTQ individuals.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?
Gold answer: LGBTQ+ individuals
Model response: The adoption agency is LGBTQ supportive, meaning they support LGBTQ individuals.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q86",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?",
 "gold": "LGBTQ+ individuals",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1739,
 "retrieval_ms": 5694.9,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "adopt",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "provides",
   "object": "support",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "passed interviews",
   "object": "adoption agency interviews",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "views adoption as",
   "object": "way of giving back",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to provide",
   "object": "support to others",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "sought advice about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "supportive people",
   "predicate": "supports",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to enable",
   "object": "people having support",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to provide",
   "object": "support for others",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "contacted mentor for",
   "object": "adoption advice",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "suggests finding",
   "object": "adoption agency or lawyer",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has mentor",
   "object": "adoption mentor",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "offers help with",
   "object": "adoption process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "action",
   "object": "applied to adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "additional source",
   "object": "supportive people",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied this week",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "ready for adoption",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "adopt children",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "chose",
   "object": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "chose agency because",
   "object": "lgbtq+ support",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks",
   "object": "adoption agency",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "adoption research answer",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching multiple",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
   "predicate": "attracts",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"provides\",\n  \"object\": \"support\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"passed interviews\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency interviews\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views adoption as\",\n  \"object\": \"way of giving back\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to provide\",\n  \"object\": \"support to others\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sought advice about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline adoption journey\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"supportive people\",\n  \"predicate\": \"supports\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to enable\",\n  \"object\": \"people having support\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to provide\",\n  \"object\": \"support for others\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"contacted mentor for\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"suggests finding\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency or lawyer\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has mentor\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption mentor\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"offers help with\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"action\",\n  \"object\": \"applied to adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"additional source\",\n  \"object\": \"supportive people\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied this week\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"ready for adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"chose\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency lgbtq supportive\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"chose agency because\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq+ support\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption research answer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching multiple\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"adoption agency lgbtq supportive\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attracts\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "The adoption agency is LGBTQ supportive, meaning they support LGBTQ individuals.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What type of individuals does the adoption agency Caroline is considering support?\nGold answer: LGBTQ+ individuals\nModel response: The adoption agency is LGBTQ supportive, meaning they support LGBTQ individuals.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q87single-hop✓ correct1727 ctx tok6882 ms recall

Q: Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?

gold: because of their inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ individuals

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · intends to · adopt
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · passed interviews · adoption agency interviews
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · excited about · adoption
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · views adoption as · way of giving back
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · believes in · chosen family
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · sought advice about · adoption
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline adoption journey · type · process
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · is planning to adopt · true
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · contacted mentor for · adoption advice
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · suggests finding · adoption agency or lawyer
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has mentor · adoption mentor
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · adoption is · dream
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · offers help with · adoption process
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has view on adoption · tough but worth it
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · action · applied to adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · attended · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · received help from · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · perception · adoption big decision
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied this week · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · believes · ready for adoption
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · adopt children
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · chose · adoption agency lgbtq supportive
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · chose agency because · lgbtq+ support
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · seeks · adoption agency
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · responds · adoption research answer
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching multiple · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] adoption agency lgbtq supportive · attracts · caroline
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "adopt",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "passed interviews",
  "object": "adoption agency interviews",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excited about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "views adoption as",
  "object": "way of giving back",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "chosen family",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "sought advice about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "contacted mentor for",
  "object": "adoption advice",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "suggests finding",
  "object": "adoption agency or lawyer",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has mentor",
  "object": "adoption mentor",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "adoption is",
  "object": "dream",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "offers help with",
  "object": "adoption process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has view on adoption",
  "object": "tough but worth it",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "action",
  "object": "applied to adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perception",
  "object": "adoption big decision",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied this week",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "ready for adoption",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "adopt children",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "chose",
  "object": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "chose agency because",
  "object": "lgbtq+ support",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks",
  "object": "adoption agency",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "adoption research answer",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching multiple",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
  "predicate": "attracts",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline chose the adoption agency because it was LGBTQ+ supportive.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?
Gold answer: because of their inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ individuals
Model response: Caroline chose the adoption agency because it was LGBTQ+ supportive.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q87",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?",
 "gold": "because of their inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ individuals",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1727,
 "retrieval_ms": 6882.2,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "adopt",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "passed interviews",
   "object": "adoption agency interviews",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excited about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "views adoption as",
   "object": "way of giving back",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "chosen family",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "sought advice about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "contacted mentor for",
   "object": "adoption advice",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "suggests finding",
   "object": "adoption agency or lawyer",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has mentor",
   "object": "adoption mentor",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "adoption is",
   "object": "dream",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "offers help with",
   "object": "adoption process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has view on adoption",
   "object": "tough but worth it",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "action",
   "object": "applied to adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perception",
   "object": "adoption big decision",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied this week",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "ready for adoption",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "adopt children",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "chose",
   "object": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "chose agency because",
   "object": "lgbtq+ support",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks",
   "object": "adoption agency",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "adoption research answer",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching multiple",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "adoption agency lgbtq supportive",
   "predicate": "attracts",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"passed interviews\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency interviews\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excited about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views adoption as\",\n  \"object\": \"way of giving back\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"chosen family\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sought advice about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline adoption journey\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is planning to adopt\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"contacted mentor for\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"suggests finding\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency or lawyer\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has mentor\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption mentor\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"adoption is\",\n  \"object\": \"dream\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"offers help with\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has view on adoption\",\n  \"object\": \"tough but worth it\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"action\",\n  \"object\": \"applied to adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perception\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption big decision\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied this week\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"ready for adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"chose\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency lgbtq supportive\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"chose agency because\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq+ support\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption research answer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching multiple\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"adoption agency lgbtq supportive\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attracts\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline chose the adoption agency because it was LGBTQ+ supportive.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: Why did Caroline choose the adoption agency?\nGold answer: because of their inclusivity and support for LGBTQ+ individuals\nModel response: Caroline chose the adoption agency because it was LGBTQ+ supportive.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q88single-hop✓ correct1705 ctx tok6989 ms recall

Q: What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?

gold: creating a family for kids who need one

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · attended · adoption council meeting
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · intends to · adopt
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · passed interviews · adoption agency interviews
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · excited about · adoption
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · views adoption as · way of giving back
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · values · acceptance
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · sought advice about · adoption
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline adoption journey · type · process
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · future intent · exciting
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · is planning to adopt · true
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has mentor · adoption mentor
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · adoption is · dream
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · offers help with · adoption process
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has view on adoption · tough but worth it
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · attended · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional state · excited
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · received help from · adoption advice assistance group
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotion · excited for future
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied to · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · perception · adoption big decision
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · applied this week · adoption agencies
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · believes · ready for adoption
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · adopt children
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · feels · hopeful
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · seeks · adoption agency
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · responds · adoption research answer
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · researching multiple · adoption agencies
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · emotional state · hopeful
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · type · person
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · gained hope from · becoming nicole
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] caroline · responds · encouragement
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · art significance · transition
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] caroline · type · person
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] caroline · reveals motivation · support similar issues
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · emotional significance · special moment
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · shared image · image painting red blue easel

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "adoption council meeting",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "adopt",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "passed interviews",
  "object": "adoption agency interviews",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excited about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "views adoption as",
  "object": "way of giving back",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "values",
  "object": "acceptance",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "sought advice about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "future intent",
  "object": "exciting",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has mentor",
  "object": "adoption mentor",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "adoption is",
  "object": "dream",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "offers help with",
  "object": "adoption process",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has view on adoption",
  "object": "tough but worth it",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "emotional state",
  "object": "excited",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "received help from",
  "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "emotion",
  "object": "excited for future",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied to",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perception",
  "object": "adoption big decision",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "applied this week",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "ready for adoption",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "adopt children",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "feels",
  "object": "hopeful",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "seeks",
  "object": "adoption agency",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "adoption research answer",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "researching multiple",
  "object": "adoption agencies",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "emotional state",
  "object": "hopeful",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "relieved",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "sharing stories builds community",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared",
  "object": "image family yard",
  "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "type",
  "object": "person",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "gained hope from",
  "object": "becoming nicole",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "encouragement",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "art significance",
  "object": "transition",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Caroline is excited about adoption itself, viewing it as a way of giving back. It's her dream and she values acceptance in the process.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?
Gold answer: creating a family for kids who need one
Model response: Caroline is excited about adoption itself, viewing it as a way of giving back. It's her dream and she values acceptance in the process.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q88",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?",
 "gold": "creating a family for kids who need one",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1705,
 "retrieval_ms": 6989.4,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "adoption council meeting",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "adopt",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "passed interviews",
   "object": "adoption agency interviews",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excited about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "views adoption as",
   "object": "way of giving back",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "values",
   "object": "acceptance",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "sought advice about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline adoption journey",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "future intent",
   "object": "exciting",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has mentor",
   "object": "adoption mentor",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "adoption is",
   "object": "dream",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "offers help with",
   "object": "adoption process",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has view on adoption",
   "object": "tough but worth it",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional state",
   "object": "excited",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "received help from",
   "object": "adoption advice assistance group",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotion",
   "object": "excited for future",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied to",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perception",
   "object": "adoption big decision",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "applied this week",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "ready for adoption",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "adopt children",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "feels",
   "object": "hopeful",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "seeks",
   "object": "adoption agency",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "adoption research answer",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "researching multiple",
   "object": "adoption agencies",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional state",
   "object": "hopeful",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "gained hope from",
   "object": "becoming nicole",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "encouragement",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "art significance",
   "object": "transition",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "type",
   "object": "person",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "reveals motivation",
   "object": "support similar issues",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "emotional significance",
   "object": "special moment",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared image",
   "object": "image painting red blue easel",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption council meeting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"passed interviews\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency interviews\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excited about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views adoption as\",\n  \"object\": \"way of giving back\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"values\",\n  \"object\": \"acceptance\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sought advice about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline adoption journey\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"future intent\",\n  \"object\": \"exciting\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is planning to adopt\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has mentor\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption mentor\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"adoption is\",\n  \"object\": \"dream\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"offers help with\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption process\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has view on adoption\",\n  \"object\": \"tough but worth it\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional state\",\n  \"object\": \"excited\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"received help from\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption advice assistance group\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotion\",\n  \"object\": \"excited for future\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied to\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perception\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption big decision\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"applied this week\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"ready for adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"feels\",\n  \"object\": \"hopeful\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agency\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption research answer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"researching multiple\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption agencies\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional state\",\n  \"object\": \"hopeful\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relieved\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"sharing stories builds community\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared\",\n  \"object\": \"image family yard\",\n  \"text\": \"[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"type\",\n  \"object\": \"person\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"gained hope from\",\n  \"object\": \"becoming nicole\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"encouragement\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art significance\",\n  \"object\": \"transition\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Caroline is excited about adoption itself, viewing it as a way of giving back. It's her dream and she values acceptance in the process.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What is Caroline excited about in the adoption process?\nGold answer: creating a family for kids who need one\nModel response: Caroline is excited about adoption itself, viewing it as a way of giving back. It's her dream and she values acceptance in the process.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}

conv-26_q89single-hop✓ correct1685 ctx tok6722 ms recall

Q: What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?

gold: she thinks Caroline is doing something amazing and will be an awesome mom

▸ retrieved claims (45)

[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023] melanie · relationship to · caroline
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · appreciates · caroline concern
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] caroline · intends to · adopt
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · excited about · adoption
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · views adoption as · way of giving back
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · agrees with · caroline
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · considers · caroline inspiring
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · believes in · chosen family
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] melanie · considers · caroline strong
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · sought advice about · adoption
[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023] melanie · responded to · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · asked about feeling of · caroline
[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023] melanie · asked about · caroline
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · perceives · caroline has guts
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · perceives in · caroline
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · is planning to adopt · true
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · adoption is · dream
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] caroline · has view on adoption · tough but worth it
[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023] melanie · seeks advice from · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · perception · adoption big decision
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] melanie · emotional response target · caroline
[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023] caroline · believes · ready for adoption
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · talked to · melanie
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · talked to · caroline
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · asks about · caroline feelings
[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023] melanie · asks · question about caroline plans
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · wants to · adopt children
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · thinks of · caroline
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] melanie · believes about · caroline as mother
[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023] caroline · responds · adoption research answer
[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023] melanie · went camping · mountain camping trip
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] melanie · art impact · helped her
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · expressed admiration · painting of woman
[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023] caroline · label · caroline
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] melanie · has child · melanie daughter
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] caroline · attended event · lgbtq conference
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] caroline · commented on · outdoor enjoyment
[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023] melanie · owns footwear · pink sneakers
[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023] caroline · shared painting · painting with brush
[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023] melanie · part of · session 2023 08 28
[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023] caroline · relieved · true
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · believes · sharing stories builds community
[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023] melanie · found · purple flowers
[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023] melanie · attributes quality · you've got guts
[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023] caroline · shared · image family yard

readerholo3.1

▸ input prompt

You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'


QUESTION: What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?

MEMORIES (JSON):
[
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "relationship to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "appreciates",
  "object": "caroline concern",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "intends to",
  "object": "adopt",
  "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "excited about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "views adoption as",
  "object": "way of giving back",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "agrees with",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "caroline inspiring",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes in",
  "object": "chosen family",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "considers",
  "object": "caroline strong",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "sought advice about",
  "object": "adoption",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "responded to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about feeling of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asked about",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "perceives",
  "object": "caroline has guts",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "perceives in",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
  "object": "true",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "adoption is",
  "object": "dream",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "has view on adoption",
  "object": "tough but worth it",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "seeks advice from",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "perception",
  "object": "adoption big decision",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "emotional response target",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "believes",
  "object": "ready for adoption",
  "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "talked to",
  "object": "melanie",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "talked to",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks about",
  "object": "caroline feelings",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "asks",
  "object": "question about caroline plans",
  "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "wants to",
  "object": "adopt children",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "thinks of",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "believes about",
  "object": "caroline as mother",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "responds",
  "object": "adoption research answer",
  "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "went camping",
  "object": "mountain camping trip",
  "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "art impact",
  "object": "helped her",
  "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "expressed admiration",
  "object": "painting of woman",
  "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "label",
  "object": "caroline",
  "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "has child",
  "object": "melanie daughter",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "attended event",
  "object": "lgbtq conference",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "commented on",
  "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "owns footwear",
  "object": "pink sneakers",
  "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "caroline",
  "predicate": "shared painting",
  "object": "painting with brush",
  "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 },
 {
  "subject": "melanie",
  "predicate": "part of",
  "object": "session 2023 08 28",
  "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]",
  "source": "search"
 }
]

Final answer:

Melanie agrees with Caroline's decision to adopt, considers her inspiring and strong, and believes she would be a good mother.

judgeholo3.1✓ correct

▸ input prompt

You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.

Question: What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?
Gold answer: she thinks Caroline is doing something amazing and will be an awesome mom
Model response: Melanie agrees with Caroline's decision to adopt, considers her inspiring and strong, and believes she would be a good mother.

Think step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.

After reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:
VERDICT: CORRECT
or
VERDICT: WRONG

VERDICT: CORRECT

▸ full JSON record

{
 "qid": "conv-26_q89",
 "category": 4,
 "question": "What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?",
 "gold": "she thinks Caroline is doing something amazing and will be an awesome mom",
 "correct": true,
 "ctx_tokens": 1685,
 "retrieval_ms": 6721.7,
 "recall": [
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "relationship to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "appreciates",
   "object": "caroline concern",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "intends to",
   "object": "adopt",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "excited about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "views adoption as",
   "object": "way of giving back",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "agrees with",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "caroline inspiring",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes in",
   "object": "chosen family",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "considers",
   "object": "caroline strong",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "sought advice about",
   "object": "adoption",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "responded to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about feeling of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asked about",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "perceives",
   "object": "caroline has guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "perceives in",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "is planning to adopt",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "adoption is",
   "object": "dream",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "has view on adoption",
   "object": "tough but worth it",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "seeks advice from",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "perception",
   "object": "adoption big decision",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "emotional response target",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "ready for adoption",
   "text": "[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "talked to",
   "object": "melanie",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "talked to",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks about",
   "object": "caroline feelings",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "asks",
   "object": "question about caroline plans",
   "text": "[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "wants to",
   "object": "adopt children",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "thinks of",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "believes about",
   "object": "caroline as mother",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "responds",
   "object": "adoption research answer",
   "text": "[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "went camping",
   "object": "mountain camping trip",
   "text": "[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "art impact",
   "object": "helped her",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "expressed admiration",
   "object": "painting of woman",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "label",
   "object": "caroline",
   "text": "[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "has child",
   "object": "melanie daughter",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "attended event",
   "object": "lgbtq conference",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "commented on",
   "object": "outdoor enjoyment",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "owns footwear",
   "object": "pink sneakers",
   "text": "[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared painting",
   "object": "painting with brush",
   "text": "[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "part of",
   "object": "session 2023 08 28",
   "text": "[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "relieved",
   "object": "true",
   "text": "[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "believes",
   "object": "sharing stories builds community",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "found",
   "object": "purple flowers",
   "text": "[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "melanie",
   "predicate": "attributes quality",
   "object": "you've got guts",
   "text": "[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]"
  },
  {
   "subject": "caroline",
   "predicate": "shared",
   "object": "image family yard",
   "text": "[7:55 pm on 9 June, 2023]"
  }
 ],
 "reader_prompt": "You are a question-answering assistant with access to retrieved memories from past conversations between two speakers. Answer the question using ONLY the memories. Be concise — answer with the specific fact(s) asked for, no preamble. Dates in memories may be in-band ('[Session date: ...]') or in valid-time metadata; use them for any time-based reasoning. If the answer genuinely cannot be determined from the memories, say 'Not enough information.'\n\n\nQUESTION: What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?\n\nMEMORIES (JSON):\n[\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"relationship to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:33 pm on 25 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"appreciates\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline concern\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"intends to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:51 pm on 15 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"excited about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"views adoption as\",\n  \"object\": \"way of giving back\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"agrees with\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline inspiring\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes in\",\n  \"object\": \"chosen family\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"considers\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline strong\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"sought advice about\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responded to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:50 pm on 17 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about feeling of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asked about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[8:56 pm on 20 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perceives\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline has guts\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perceives in\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"is planning to adopt\",\n  \"object\": \"true\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"adoption is\",\n  \"object\": \"dream\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has view on adoption\",\n  \"object\": \"tough but worth it\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"seeks advice from\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:31 am on 13 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"perception\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption big decision\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"emotional response target\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes\",\n  \"object\": \"ready for adoption\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:31 pm on 23 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"talked to\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"talked to\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline feelings\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"asks\",\n  \"object\": \"question about caroline plans\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:36 pm on 3 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"wants to\",\n  \"object\": \"adopt children\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"thinks of\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"believes about\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline as mother\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"responds\",\n  \"object\": \"adoption research answer\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:14 pm on 25 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"went camping\",\n  \"object\": \"mountain camping trip\",\n  \"text\": \"[10:37 am on 27 June, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"art impact\",\n  \"object\": \"helped her\",\n  \"text\": \"[12:09 am on 13 September, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"expressed admiration\",\n  \"object\": \"painting of woman\",\n  \"text\": \"[1:56 pm on 8 May, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"label\",\n  \"object\": \"caroline\",\n  \"text\": \"[9:55 am on 22 October, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"has child\",\n  \"object\": \"melanie daughter\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"attended event\",\n  \"object\": \"lgbtq conference\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"commented on\",\n  \"object\": \"outdoor enjoyment\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"owns footwear\",\n  \"object\": \"pink sneakers\",\n  \"text\": \"[4:33 pm on 12 July, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"caroline\",\n  \"predicate\": \"shared painting\",\n  \"object\": \"painting with brush\",\n  \"text\": \"[2:24 pm on 14 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n },\n {\n  \"subject\": \"melanie\",\n  \"predicate\": \"part of\",\n  \"object\": \"session 2023 08 28\",\n  \"text\": \"[3:19 pm on 28 August, 2023]\",\n  \"source\": \"search\"\n }\n]\n\nFinal answer:",
 "reader_output": "Melanie agrees with Caroline's decision to adopt, considers her inspiring and strong, and believes she would be a good mother.",
 "judge_prompt": "You are grading a question-answering system's response against a gold answer, for questions about long conversations between two people.\n\nQuestion: What does Melanie think about Caroline's decision to adopt?\nGold answer: she thinks Caroline is doing something amazing and will be an awesome mom\nModel response: Melanie agrees with Caroline's decision to adopt, considers her inspiring and strong, and believes she would be a good mother.\n\nThink step by step about whether the model response contains (or is equivalent to) the gold answer. The response may be more verbose than the gold answer, or word things differently — that is fine as long as the asked-for information is present and correct. For temporal questions, accept answers that clearly refer to the same date/time even if formatted differently. For list-style answers, the response must cover the substance of the gold answer, not just a subset, to count as correct.\n\nAfter reasoning, output a final line in exactly this format:\nVERDICT: CORRECT\nor\nVERDICT: WRONG",
 "judge_output": "VERDICT: CORRECT",
 "reader_model": "holo3.1",
 "judge_model": "holo3.1",
 "backend": "hyades"
}